Bay 12 Games Forum

Toony - Town Stem
NQT - Town Root
Tric - claims Stem
Web - "claims" Stem
Max - acts like Flower, is likely Root or Flower
Jim - ??
Jack - ??
Fluffe - ??
a1s - ??

If Web is telling the truth and town then we lose if the other Town Root dies.

Jim - ??
Jack - ??
Fluffe - ??
a1s - ??

Fluffe seems town.
Jack is annoying but maybe town?

I think mafia has to be either Jim/a1s, Jack/a1s, or Jim/Jack if I believe Fluffe and Max are town.

Jim/a1s - seems the most likely
Jack/a1s - a lot of evidence doesn't support this
Jim/Jack - doesn't seem likely

Jack/Max? - End of Day 2 doesn't look like that
Max/a1s? - unlikely a1s has done jackall except say scum are me and Max

I think mafia always kill here on N2 since if I was mafia I would try to kill the other Root player which wins the game on the spot.

If mafia are Jim/a1s then Jim probably kills because a1s is more suspicious and more likely to be blocked. I don't think they worry about Jim being tracked, that's the biggest concern they would have though.

Having a1s kill instead means it's more likely the kill is blocked, seems less worth it.

NQT's last reads puts Max and Web are most suspicious, but not both together. Jim, Jack, and a1s are fairly low.

Jim wants to pursue Max/NQT/Jack which would make sense for mafia!Jim if it's Jim/a1s.

I let Web choose between a1s or NQT at EOD2 which should be soft evidence I'm not with a1s. Toony/Max or Toony/Jim are the most probable teams you could argue with Toony/Max being the most convincing.

Fluffe thinks it's a1s with maybe Jim or me.

Max/Fluffe seems possible but I guess we just lose to that.

Meh. I think it's maybe Jim and a1s but at best mafia have a 1/3 chance of winning the game tonight so I don't think blocking someone is correct, although I probably block Jim here if it wasn't one-shot. Not blocking is also good if I'm wrong. I think if Fluffe is town he's actually the best kill target here, but sadly I can't protect.