Bay 12 Games Forum

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Advanced search  

Show Posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.

Messages - ToonyMan

Pages: 1 ... 56 57 [58] 59 60 ... 1978
856
Mafia / Re: Wormwood Mafia - Day Three
« on: March 07, 2023, 10:00:40 pm »
Which players do you think have no chance of being Max's partner?
Me, you, a1s, and jim those are the people with 0% chance in my eyes of being mafia (with me only being from my POV)
I agree.

If we vote Jack today and he's town, can you block Tric tonight?

857
Mafia / Re: Wormwood Mafia - Day Three
« on: March 07, 2023, 05:23:43 pm »
I disagree Jack had low town cred cause alot of people (including me) thought/think he is good because of his breakdown around the first day I say it's closer to high middling.
Which players do you think have no chance of being Max's partner?

858
Mafia / Re: Wormwood Mafia - Day Three
« on: March 07, 2023, 05:10:23 pm »
Removing myself, NQT, and a1s...

At the End of Day 2, where did town cred lie?

Who were players with high town cred? Tric and Fluffe. (me, NQT, Web, and most others vouched for these players)

Who were players with middling town cred? Jim and Web. (some of us vouched for these players but not all)

Who were players with low town cred? Jack and Max. (not a lot of us vouched for these players)

Does everyone agree with this?

859
Mafia / Re: Wormwood Mafia - Day Three
« on: March 07, 2023, 05:01:15 pm »
Did you notice how long Max was confused about the hammer drop?
Probably a minute if he's even being honest. By the time I responded to his first post he had already corrected himself.

Fluffe didn't seem to notice at all because they responded to my question with reads.
Here.
I mean I knew you weren't hammered because I knew NQT changed his vote to me even double-checked once Tric/Max started acting confused about it to make sure.
I did the same thing, this sounds honest.

Did Mafia want a Toony Lynch?
I don't think they cared.

Theory: Mafia planned to kill one of their own Night 2 during/prior to Day 2, in order to avoid town's roleblocks and protects.
It's true, killing one of your own guys means if a block or protect gets in the way at least...you don't kill each other. It's fucking bad if a Flower tracks you though.

Here's the thing:

There's probably no reason to kill your own guy unless you think your partner is in deep cover (has a lot of town cred) and want to just quickly identify the last Root for game. If you wanted to avoid blocks and protects you could simply do nothing and now you have two mafia instead of one for the next day.

The other possibility is that maybe mafia thought it was likely Max would be lynched on Day 3 (it's certainly possible) and they probably also thought I would be an easy scapegoat for Day 3 the same way I was for Day 2 if Max flipped mafia. If Max was around for Day 3 there's a good chance he gets lynched first before me which means killing the last Root would not let them win.

860
Mafia / Re: Wormwood Mafia - Day Three
« on: March 07, 2023, 11:33:19 am »
Fluffe didn't seem to notice at all because they responded to my question with reads.
Here.

861
Mafia / Re: Wormwood Mafia - Day Three
« on: March 07, 2023, 11:28:35 am »
Fluffe didn't seem to notice at all because they responded to my question with reads.

862
Mafia / Re: Wormwood Mafia - Day Three
« on: March 07, 2023, 11:24:43 am »
Tric isn't it weird how you and Max both thought I got hammered on D2 when you voted me?

863
Mafia / Re: Wormwood Mafia - Day Three
« on: March 07, 2023, 08:07:13 am »
I want to know which one of you is the last Stem, and which one of you is the last Flower.
I am the last Stem. And I still have my block.
And I'm the mayor of Whoville.

864
Mafia / Re: Wormwood Mafia - Day Three
« on: March 07, 2023, 01:35:42 am »
I guess I can at least make more accurate mafia interaction reads compared to last time where all I saw was a lot of nothing between a1s/Jack/Fluffe/NQT.

Tric blocking Max last night is the most Tric thing ever since it's the second worst thing he could have done N2.
Jim is just town.
a1s is confirmed town.

I'm not looking at these players, if it's one of them then whatever we lose. Tric is the most likely, but he's acting so much like himself.

Possible partners are Jack, Fluffe, and Webadict. What makes me uncomfortable is that mafia willingly chose to kill Max, so they were confident enough to go for this play. This also suggests to me that mafia have a Flower which I think makes Jack and Web more suspect.

I am seriously considering Web here I think because Web/Max totally does this, and I want to hear his insight about the other two.

Fluffe ranges from feeling really town to I don't know what this guy is thinking.

Jack has been relatively suspicious this whole game and treated me bad on D2, although this might have been because they're mad at me?

To do in the future:
1. Max/Web - thoughts
2. Max/Jack - thoughts
3. Max/Fluffe - thoughts

We just need to be right within two players.

865
Mafia / Re: Wormwood Mafia - Day Three
« on: March 07, 2023, 01:17:10 am »
Well I guess we don't have to do it that way since the end result is the same, but it's funny we can do that because of how blocks work.

866
Mafia / Re: Wormwood Mafia - Day Three
« on: March 07, 2023, 01:09:40 am »
Sir, I shall take you up on that offer!

I am a Flower. I tracked Jim, and saw him visit Toony.

I think, if folks look at how I have acted throughout the game, it should support that I was a tracker all along.
Alright then well there you go now you know what role I am also I will add that I have not used my ability yet.
Interesting.

New plan.

We lynch Web today.

I block Fluffe tonight.

Fluffe blocks Jack tonight.

If Web is mafia we win.

If Fluffe is mafia then he can't kill a1s and we go to D4 to decide between Fluffe and Jack.

If Jack is mafia then blocks can't stop blocks so Fluffe stops Jack from killing a1s and we go to D4 to decide between Fluffe and Jack.

This way we can remove Web as a possible suspect while still getting a choice between Fluffe and Jack if it's not him. Web should be okay with this because he can give as much thoughts as he wants about Jack and Fluffe if he's town.

867
Mafia / Re: Wormwood Mafia - Day Three
« on: March 06, 2023, 10:49:43 pm »
I mean if mafia kill the root tonight it's game over so having them have to guess who among us is the Root rather than mass claiming is probably a good idea.

Let me rephrase my question.

a1s is almost certainly the Root, but on the weird off chance either you or Jack is the Root then all you literally have to do is claim Root and you're confirmed town and thus win the argument against the other.

I want to know which one of you is the last Stem, and which one of you is the last Flower.

But confirming either of us doesn't help us find the mafia does it? Like I aint the Root but in the off chance Jack is the Root id rather mafia have that uncertainty about it I rather not potentially throw the game by role claiming unless it is 100% guaranteed to net us a mafia.

I'd rather not waste my time thinking whether a player is mafia if they're confirmed town.

868
Mafia / Re: Wormwood Mafia - Day Three
« on: March 06, 2023, 10:45:44 pm »
Toony - Town Stem
Tric - Stem

NQT - Town Root
Max - Mafia Root
a1s - almost certainly Root

Web - Flower
Jim - Flower

Jack - ?
Fluffe - ?

There isn't any wiggle room at this point, we can't hide who last Root is.

869
Mafia / Re: Wormwood Mafia - Day Three
« on: March 06, 2023, 10:41:42 pm »
I mean if mafia kill the root tonight it's game over so having them have to guess who among us is the Root rather than mass claiming is probably a good idea.
Let me rephrase my question.

a1s is almost certainly the Root, but on the weird off chance either you or Jack is the Root then all you literally have to do is claim Root and you're confirmed town and thus win the argument against the other.

I want to know which one of you is the last Stem, and which one of you is the last Flower.

870
Mafia / Re: Wormwood Mafia - Day Three
« on: March 06, 2023, 09:15:06 pm »
@Fluffe9911: So who's Mafia?
The literally only option I can think of is webadict if it aint him then I frankly don't know maybe tric's been pulling us along for a ride secretly this whole time.
Try to convince me it's Webadict, I'm listening.

Pages: 1 ... 56 57 [58] 59 60 ... 1978