Bay 12 Games Forum

We can probably conclude Jim is telling the truth about his tracking Toony, since he chose to jump in and scream at everyone instead of hammering.
So, it appears Toony & Jim are cleared.

Jim is most likely town, yes. We literally aren't winning if they're mafia because they're the one player who actually helps me.

Current feelings:
Jim is town. Tric is town. Web is town. a1s is town.

More likely to vote Fluffe, if we're wrong then I block Jack tonight. Thus sealing the game as long as we can guess correct within two players.

I want to read the game over again while looking closely at Fluffe and Jack. Web is like a distant third I guess, but I'm really not seeing it.

pheeeeew

Can we all put our heads together now and figure out who last mafia is?

Quote from: Jim Groovester on March 06, 2023, 01:41:03 pm

Seriously why do none of you understand the consequences of putting somebody at L-1 in a game where the mafia only need to kill one player to win.

I understand the consequences I just don't give a shit cause im not in the mental state to feel anything but unbridled rage right now. I'll unvote for now since ya gave some proof it ain't him and im gonna take a couple of hours to calm down. I hope you feel goddamn silly Jim

Why would you vote me if you said earlier you had a case for it being Web or Jim? Feeding into Tric's nonsense is almost always a losing play.

I'm at school so can't make a long post but did you guys seriously have to lynch the one guy I was almost certain was town at that point?!? Did not a single one of you read my post or think it made sense and if not why the hell did you not attack me for it! I'd vote Max right now if he was still alive god I can't believe that happened.

I read your townread of NQT and liked it, this is what makes mafia hard.

Toony, who do you think is most likely to be mafia?

I think it's more likely to be a Flower because mafia killing each other on a night where people are likely to fire their actions is super risky if a Flower catches them. We're dealing with very devious players here, I think they would be accounting for if there was two or three town flowers. It's not a guarantee obviously. Between Fluffe and Jack I'm more suspicious of Fluffe actually since a Max/Jack team benefits less from this action? I can't tell currently I need to look into it.

Throws hands into the air Fine maybe mafia are just stupid! I'll give Toonyman a shot but if it ain't him I expect you to help me figure out who it is between Web and Jim and if you somehow think it's someone else im strangling you metaphorically.

Stop throwing votes around willy-nilly, mafia can and will quickhammer me if they're sure there's no other blocks left.

I think we have to claim since a1s outed themselves without caution.

Tric we should be able to win this game as long as it's literally not Web/Max, but that would be the most mindblowing play from them. Lynching me or Web today is an extremely bad idea for various reasons.

@Toony:  True, but that's less viable for reasons.  If we can narrow it down, we can win, but we might not have any extra blocks, so it's still giving scum a potential instant win.

I still have my block.

I was going to use my ability on Max, now I'm glad I didn't.

...

Suicide? I blocked them last night, so I expect a track claim to come up against me.

Mafia can kill each other. There's no other way for mafia to die unless they deliberately kill one another, as far as I can tell.

NQT was correct to suspect Max.