Bay 12 Games Forum

I prevented Imp from using kills last night.

Would be pretty convenient for a framer to have an excuse to target those whom others are already dubious of, especially if this anti-town player also knew that no mafia assassinations could occur regardless of their actions, wouldn't it?

I'm fairly certain Oliver is our thief.  I considered impelling a Maximum Splynch if Imp's alibi turned out to be truthful because the latter protecting NJW, thus preventing the first murder, seemed like a strong argument, but the recent developments on top of the fact that the mafia have yet to kill a single person support the hypothesis that Oliver is the main antagonist, at least in my processing unit.  Something that'd be helpful to figure out is whether any of us had an opportunity to employ the hinted-at frame ability.  Spin couldn't have used it on Oliver yesterday and had previously claimed to have targeted Imp the day before--a yet-to-be-confirmed element.  Here's what I propose: we execute Oliver, and NJW spends the evening investigating me; if I also turn up as a thief, Max is the one who planted all that evidence and framed the people he paid visits to.

My flavor does not contradict that information in any way.

The following doesn't fully add up:

Your Butler is unaware of your existence on the boat due to hypnosis performed upon them.

My flavor makes it clear I have an employer, doesn't tell me anything about who.  Makes it clear I'm absolutely and completely that person's servant.  And that my job includes making sure nothing bad happens to my employer.

And does it matter that you're not answering Oliver either?

...

wait what
what does this mean

0_0

Imp

Lord Almighty, God above, grace us with an infinitesimal sliver of your fathomless wisdom.  Amen!

Unvote

I got the idea sofanthiel also saw it, right?

I saw Imp's claim to work at the local cruise mill being supported by Quarque's epitaph and how that could've been an intentional move on the pair's part.

I think that mafia being double godfathers isn't unlikely

My ocular receptors envision three distinct possibilities:
1. Maximized Spine ∈ town and they lived happily ever after!
2. NJW is lying; don't believe his lies.
3. We are all trapped within an undisclosed !!BASTARD!!

I find one of the above vastly more plausible than the others, and thus will stick to it unless sufficient evidence presents itself.