Firstly, yes I have read Hawking's novel, and yes, I disagree with it. The fact that it relies on black holes, charge-neutral interstellar space and wishy washy dark matter concepts is why I discount it.
You know they recently discovered actual evidence in favor of dark matter?
http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2008/10/081020135219.htmIt's not conclusive proof, but it's observed evidence that backs up the predictions made by people like Hawking decades earlier. Naturally if dark matter exists trillions of miles away or more, we're not going to be able to get first-hand evidence until our technology improves.
Also, there's piles of observed evidence for black holes. The term "gravitational lensing" comes to mind.
http://www.damtp.cam.ac.uk/user/gr/public/bh_obsv.htmlyou can talk about the effects of magnetism as much as you like, they're well known, well reproducible, understood and accepted. What I am trying to get through to people is that we know what it does, just not why or how.
What I'm trying to get through to you is that just because YOU don't understand the mechanics by which magnetism works, your ignorance does not invalidate or question the qualification of literally thousands of scientists (like, well, that Osmosis Jones feller) who spend their entire lifetimes researching this stuff.
by the way, before you think about "not attacking" me, try not suggesting I didn't get through high school. I may not have degree level qualifications, but my level of knowledge is far from basic.
Well, when you say things like, "there's no peer-reviewed publications dealing with the mechanics of magnetism", you come across as a high school freshman who rented "What the Bleep Do We Know?" last night and is now going to OMGWTFPWN his physics teacher. When you confuse (deliberately or otherwise, I honestly can't tell if you're joking) the scientific method with "faith", it makes you look even worse.
You see, this is why I call myself a Heretic. I dare to question the assumptions that underly our theories. You who blindly follow the current faithscientific method are the ones who need to open your eyes.
But, see, I don't "blindly" follow anything. Magnetic theory has given us things like the electric motor and, well, that computer that you're reading this post on. If I'm blinded by faith (I'm not), I'd say my faith is justified. Science has a darn fine track record.
The scientific method isn't about blindly following what came before. It's about constantly questioning everything. For a long time, science believed that the "atom" was the smallest possible particle, and atoms could never be split. Now we have nuclear reactors, and you can even build your own Geiger counter with a kit from Radio Shack. Science still doesn't know "why" a particular uranium atom undergoes radioactive decay while the one next to it just sits there, but that doesn't invalidate nuclear theory or indicate some "blind faith" on the part of the "establishment".
Again, I must say, I'm NOT attacking YOU PERSONALLY. You made a ridiculous statement and I'm pointing out the flaws in your reasoning. Now, I COULD write ten pages on electron spin and quantum interactions, but I'm admittedly not qualified to teach quantum mechanics or calculus, so I can't show you the equations that describe magnetic force and say, "this is how magnetism works" in a way that you OR I would understand. Here's a couple of links for your further edification.
http://www.coolmagnetman.com/maghow.htmhttp://www.physicsforums.com/showthread.php?t=96769If this isn't enough information, make a new thread about it on the physicsforums. Just be a little more careful in your phrasing. If you go all thermonuclear on there with some "there are no peer-reviewed articles on the mechanics of magnetism" crap, they will quite reasonably dismiss you as an Alex Jones type crackpot. If, on the other hand, you are civil and reasonable, and say something along the lines of, "I'm not aware of the mechanism by which magnetism works, could you point me to some good peer-reviewed articles on the subject", I don't doubt that you will get all the information you need.