331
DF Community Games & Stories / Re: Museum III, adventure succession game
« on: March 08, 2022, 09:38:55 am »
Before I start, nobody should take anything here personal, the rules are rather complex, and it's expected that some differences in interpretation of those rules exist. It is helpfull to to have issues with the rules pointed out every now and then to make sure that everyone is treated fairly and that the game can continue to move forward.
About the issue at hand, playing multiple adventurers after each other is not the intention. I think in this case only the story of the plump helmet man was published?
There have been earlier issues with this though, I know that at some point we also had a case where a new character died, and the player wrote his story from the perspective of an earlier adventurer . This was for roleplay reasons, (it was stated that the old adventurer had found the journal, and that this was the reason the story of the newer adventurer had survived). This was more or less fine as the older adventurer did not have much of an impact on the world, and only travelled to the location and back, but you can imagine that if that older adventurer had gone on to kill the law givers of two civilisations and the last dragon, it would not be ok. It is clear therefore that you quickly get into grey areas.
The best and most fair solution I think is to just not play multiple characters in succession,at all or to ask when in doubt. It is worth pointing out though that we are always having these discussions after the fact because save games and write ups are mostly completed after the adventure is done. There is no good way to deal with enforcement of rules, and I also do not want to spend my time on that.
I'm happy if stuff moves forward in the general spirit of the rules, there is no way it's all going to be perfect, but having a (short) discussion every now and then helps!
About the issue at hand, playing multiple adventurers after each other is not the intention. I think in this case only the story of the plump helmet man was published?
There have been earlier issues with this though, I know that at some point we also had a case where a new character died, and the player wrote his story from the perspective of an earlier adventurer . This was for roleplay reasons, (it was stated that the old adventurer had found the journal, and that this was the reason the story of the newer adventurer had survived). This was more or less fine as the older adventurer did not have much of an impact on the world, and only travelled to the location and back, but you can imagine that if that older adventurer had gone on to kill the law givers of two civilisations and the last dragon, it would not be ok. It is clear therefore that you quickly get into grey areas.
The best and most fair solution I think is to just not play multiple characters in succession,
I'm happy if stuff moves forward in the general spirit of the rules, there is no way it's all going to be perfect, but having a (short) discussion every now and then helps!

.