Bay 12 Games Forum

also Mindmaker what is your read on Ottofar?

Flintus, now that Kaminasquirtle has unvoted, you're the only one supporting elegy in his vote.
So what new evidence have you gathered, since you last posted, that would support your accusation?

I see very little real evidence as Ottofar has yet to post too much substance I do know for certain he still has not provided evidence that gives any reason for him to have been initially suspicious of elegy and his only excuse was essentially that he agreed with Azure's points and what do you know it turns out they were not based on anything either so Ottofar has essentially just voted for Elegy because someone else was.

I am almost certain that Ottofar is scum.

Also he is yet to come up with a reasonable defence for his actions and is instead just trying to shift suspicion onto Elegy

Fair enough

Anyways just a heads up that I will be gone for about a day so any questions will take awhile to recieve an answer.

Quote from: Murphy on October 23, 2010, 02:39:59 am

Quote from: Ottofar on October 23, 2010, 02:03:39 am

Murphy, what do you think of having three votes on you this early?

It is likely to find at least one scum in a group of three. And I think that two mafia players are likely to vote for the same person. So if one of the three is a scum, there's a good possibility that another one is, too. So there's good possibility that among these three we have both mafia players.

Of course, if both mafia players are experienced, they would not give away such an obvious sign, but we are playing beginners' mafia, aren't we?

If that's your opinion do you have any idea which of the three is most likely to be scum?

Murphy I'll ask again if someone of thre three voting for you is likely to be scum do you have any idea which of them it would be??

Quote from: Flintus10 on October 23, 2010, 02:09:53 am

and Ottofar again Your vote is still on Elegy and your question insinuated that your were quite sure he was scum did you have proof or did you just misword it?

I find him scum. He appears to be protecting Murphy.

Really Ottofar you don't seem to have provided any evidence of this is it possible you are just going on Azure's opinion without formulating one on your own, scum?

Quote from: ragnarok97071 on October 22, 2010, 05:18:37 pm

Murphy: Why did you join a game which you yourself said that you probably would not like?

Also @Ragnarok
probably just a newbie mistake but adding a third vote to someone for absolutely no reason during RVS is reasonably suspicious and looks like a bandwagon vote so slight FOS on you for that scummy action.

Ah right no sorry that "Also" is a typo I was was just quoting ragnarok for proof that he put the vote on you.

Also Ottofar I'd prefer doctor as it would allow me to operate more efficiently without the need for myself to roleclaim.

and Ottofar again Your vote is still on Elegy and your question insinuated that your were quite sure he was scum did you have proof or did you just misword it?

Quote from: Flintus10 on October 22, 2010, 04:25:41 pm

KaminaSquirtle What exactly is it about Elegy that makes him a good mafia player??

I don't really know, he just seems like he would be good at being scum.  And the question concerned scumbuddies, so yeah.
Flintus10, what do you think is the best way to play town?

[/b]
Straight back at me eh?

Your answer is good enough though you could elaborate a bit more on exactly what makes a good scum player and why you believe Elegy fits that. (Though if you don't know you don't know that's cool)


And I'd say good town play involves being active and observant in scum hunting and making sure to use your vote wisely. Of course every player is different and has different guidlines.