Bay 12 Games Forum

Quote from: Vector on October 29, 2009, 10:17:16 pm

Active, perhaps, but not being helpful.

And what about you?  Have anything to say?  You haven't been particularly talkative recently...

well, I have something from Night One I don't know how to deal with at ALL, as PMs are not allowed in this game. Since I've been thinking and sitting on it for a bit, I may as well throw it out there. Someone has Amnesiac Cop power, which told me Vector was Town.

Org IS being more helpful than Eduren. Some content is more than none.

What's your point, though?  Trying to keep the heat off Org?

I'm voting eduren for a reason.  I want Org to learn to show up and talk, though.

Right now, I think eduren is one of our scum-brigade.  Not sure who else might be, though.

... Right!  I'm a moron.

Everyone inspects the dude I kill.  For some reason I always think in pairs >_>

Yeah.  I want my vote still on eduren, but still...


Org, show up and be useful, please.

Ah, true.  That does pretty much turn it into a guessing game, because we have to hit the bishops first and we can't find 'em.

So... honestly, I trawled through this thing and have been following along the entire time, but I'm not quite sure what to say about it.  I feel like AN is playing clumsily and making beginner mistakes, but it's not like that's a scumtell or something.

If AN is looking for a particular yellow, as has been posited, then he shouldn't be testing for that with Twiggie.  This game is a closed system, remember?  We had 12 players, and now we have 13.  As such, AN cannot be looking for whatever Twiggie specifically is.  He could be looking for a class of yellows, but otherwise he's just rolefishing like mad.

That said, I've seen him do that as town in a handful of other games, so there you go.

If this is too obvious, I apologize (though it's a bit odd that Webadict didn't mention this conclusion, himself).  That said, your list fails to contain Twiggie, who is active-lurking all the way down the street.  Given that he's playing exactly the same as he played last time (and was scum then), I would like to see him come out and talk some more.

Could be fun, but I think we should try to let some of the other stuff wind down first.  We've got a really big set going right now, and I think some of the games are suffering because of it.

Also, NSBM2 is probably going to be able to begin soon, so... well, think about it, anyway.

Bah, sorry.

I wish to re-explain:

Finding Toony's weakness should be something we're thinking about as the game progresses.  Obviously, until he's the last scum left standing, it's not the most important thing.

Mostly, I don't want to be left at lylo with unkillable scum.  That sounds like a really, really bad idea.