I always ditch the anvil. Sure, the 1000 extra points is sort of overkill, but seeing as I never use an anvil at all during the first year and only rarely in the second year, anything I buy will be more immediately useful than keeping it would be.
In my most recent fortress I brought 2 miners, 1 mason/building designer, 1 carpenter/bowyer/clothesmaker, 1 cook/brewer, 1 farmer/herbalist, and 1 politician/craftsdwarf/hauler/whatever odd jobs need doing dwarf.
The extra points allow me to keep the second axe in case something unfortunate happens to my woodcutter, and then I buy food and booze - at least 30 of each kind of alcohol, 40 turtles, then I pampered everybody with a few units of every food they had a preference for since that means they'd clear those barrels more quickly. I bought about 20 each of rocknuts and sweetpod seeds, an extra pick, then let's see...4 copper cages, 20 pieces of leather, then a few pieces of silk because I never find silk anymore and want it available for moods. The rest I spent on a couple of cats, then as many horses, donkeys, and dogs as I could afford.
My strategy was to have the miners clear a huge room in the sandy loam for farms and storage, then I sent them down to make exploratory shafts in the next three levels while my farmer planted sweetpods and rock nuts, my cook started murdering every tree in sight, my carpenter turned all my leather into bags while waiting on her to finish, and my mason ran around with my politician cramming animals into cages and hauling stuff and whatever else needed doing until there was enough stone to make a bunch of blocks for the outside wall.
By this point I've basically got a whole trading empire fueled by sweetpod and quarry leaf products, with a few of my carpenter's suckier bows thrown in. My animal population has gotten pretty big despite my often needing to take their skin away, I got my first migrant wave not too long ago and thanks to my politician making a bunch of obsidian swords and turtle bone bolts in advance my military is quickly training up. This is by far my most successful fortress and I owe a lot to all those excess points giving me a head start - sure I didn't need them, but considering I bought an anvil from the dwarf caravan that I've yet to have a use for I consider them well spent.
[ November 04, 2007: Message edited by: Solara ]