661
DF Dwarf Mode Discussion / Re: Discussion on threadnomancy. Or necrothreading. Or whatever.
« on: July 30, 2016, 01:40:19 pm »
It seems like two rather different things are being confused here: thread resurrection and thread necromancy.
When you post a new message to a "dead" thread which contributes to or otherwise renews the discussion in a meaningful way, then the thread has been resurrected. For example, somebody might post a help request in the Modding forum and never get an answer, only for somebody years later to find the thread and have the answer to that question. Thread resurrection isn't an inherently bad thing - the only real problem is that newcomers might waste a bunch of time reading through old comments which are no longer relevant. Some forums encourage reviving threads, while others encourage starting new ones (and possibly linking to the old ones); I don't recall which is preferred on the Bay 12 forums.
On the other hand, when you post a message to a dead thread which does not contribute to the discussion in any meaningful way (e.g. "Me too!" or "Hey! Read this thread, it's awesome!"), then all you have accomplished is reanimating the thread like a zombie, just like what necromancers do to dead creatures. This act is never acceptable, and such posts should ideally be Reported as abusive behavior.
When you post a new message to a "dead" thread which contributes to or otherwise renews the discussion in a meaningful way, then the thread has been resurrected. For example, somebody might post a help request in the Modding forum and never get an answer, only for somebody years later to find the thread and have the answer to that question. Thread resurrection isn't an inherently bad thing - the only real problem is that newcomers might waste a bunch of time reading through old comments which are no longer relevant. Some forums encourage reviving threads, while others encourage starting new ones (and possibly linking to the old ones); I don't recall which is preferred on the Bay 12 forums.
On the other hand, when you post a message to a dead thread which does not contribute to the discussion in any meaningful way (e.g. "Me too!" or "Hey! Read this thread, it's awesome!"), then all you have accomplished is reanimating the thread like a zombie, just like what necromancers do to dead creatures. This act is never acceptable, and such posts should ideally be Reported as abusive behavior.