Somewhat, to be more clear : No, i'm am not certain enough to put you up definitevely for lynch, i will change my vote if i get anything better. Still for now i will keep my vote on you.
Hold water or not, not responding is not helping too. If i said nothing you would have used it as further proof of scumminess.
Nope. When I first made the comment about the double post, I didn't actually think you were scummy. I just thought it was unusual, something to look back into down the road.
The only reason I'm even voting you right now is that you did over-defend yourself (and not attack anyone, but you're not the only one doing that). You've calmed down somewhat, but I still want to see you scumhunt.
If asking questions isn't your thing, there are other options. Go back in the thread and read people's posts. Look for anything contradictions or unusual behavior. Town don't have to act, so their behavior will usually be slightly more natural.
Again? On which wagon did I jump earlier? As for him, I don't think the reason is flimsy, and it had been said elsewhere by him, so it's not like he's parroting it. Neither am I, before you say it, I arrived independently at the conclusion that your attack on MBP was scummy while I was rereading, and your deflection/intimidation attempts only cemented my conclusions.
You tunnel. You've done it in two previous games I've either played or modded with you. I really don't think that I'm either deflecting or trying to be intimidating. You've said the former of me (when tunneling) and I didn't see it then and the latter is what I honestly think. The intention is *
not* to get him to shut it, it's quite the opposite. I want him to expand his case, which he's doing (not that I agree with his points, but there you have it).
Oh, are you playing the "if you lynch me you'll regret it!" card? Yeah, that's another nail in your coffin.
I do admit that the game is more fun with active players, but playing to win means lynching the scummiest, and right now that is you.
I hesitated posting that because I knew that's who you (and possibly others would react), but it's exactly my point. If you lynch me today, the Mafia kills an another of the more active players tonight, and one or more of the remaining ones is scum, they can easily just lurk to victory. Happened before, sure it will happen again. Would rather it not be this game.
There are *
always* mislynches built into Mafia. I really do think that even if you're 80% convinced I'm scum, you can always lynch me later.
