211
DF Dwarf Mode Discussion / Re: Items where steel or the blue stuff isn't necessarily better?
« on: December 28, 2010, 07:17:22 am »
For blunt weapons I think all the material properties make a difference, just not really enough to matter. Its hard to tell the difference between a broken bone and a brokener bone and it takes alot of data to reliably tell the difference between different materials getting stopped by armor 3% of the time vs 2% of the time, or whatever.
As far as anyone can tell a shield just blocks or doesn't block and material does not effect that. Now when your soldier decides to hit something with a shield, material will likely matter.
Our sciencesmiths have a couple of theories about ranged weapon performance. Heavier metals may perform better because ranged weapons have a value in the raws that determines the maximum projectile velocity. A light arrow and a heavy arrow will both be going at this maximum velocity, so the heavier arrow will just have more energy behind it. Alternatively arrows are almost as pointy as the whip (contact area 2, whip is 1), so its possible that just about any metal is sharp/hard/inelastic enough to penetrate armor arbitrarily well. The only remaining thing that makes a difference is weight (density).
As far as anyone can tell a shield just blocks or doesn't block and material does not effect that. Now when your soldier decides to hit something with a shield, material will likely matter.
Our sciencesmiths have a couple of theories about ranged weapon performance. Heavier metals may perform better because ranged weapons have a value in the raws that determines the maximum projectile velocity. A light arrow and a heavy arrow will both be going at this maximum velocity, so the heavier arrow will just have more energy behind it. Alternatively arrows are almost as pointy as the whip (contact area 2, whip is 1), so its possible that just about any metal is sharp/hard/inelastic enough to penetrate armor arbitrarily well. The only remaining thing that makes a difference is weight (density).