Also, IMO, both are good, but Minecraft is almost in its beta, and dwarf fortress has been around for like 4-5 years, and is still in alpha...
I think the difference between beta and alpha in Minecraft will be completely negligible. The differences will just be in name. And Notch has been claiming the development has been rapidly nearing beta for months now so I don't think it's almost.
Yeah, Dwarf Fortress wins considering it has a 3 year lead on Minecraft in content. It's a really unfair comparison.
Off to go make the Dwarf Fortress vs. Minecraft thread over on the other side...
EDIT: Minecraft equivalent thread
Personally, I think it's a bad idea even mentioning DF on the Minecraft forums. Not because I think it will start a flame war, but because the MC community really aren't the brand of people whose attention we should be bringing our forum to.
They will descend upon us like a school of bloodthirsty carp. The end is nigh, brethren.
This isn't the first time I've heard people speak unfavorably about the Minecraft community. What exactly is wrong with them? Their game isn't so obscure that they can pretentious about it, it isn't so mainstream that it would attract the stereotypical l33t speak moron, and it doesn't have any characters for the forum to establish creepy fanbases around (Talimancers are so fucking weird). So I don't see what would make them so bad.
Clearly there's a lot of exaggeration, but the MC forums have an unusually high concentration of trolls, and the fanbase as a whole seems to be completely unpleasable and unreasonable. They do nothing but bitch about the tiniest of things.
True, it isn't exactly mainstream, but the community's troubles seem to stem from that whole "gamer entitlement" thing. People pay $13 for a game in the alpha stage, then go on a self-important tirade when things don't work right away. The game's accessibility (while not a bad thing in itself,) doesn't help much with filtering out the very type of immature morons that plague their forums.
That said, I prefer the apples, but that doesn't make it any less impossible to compare with oranges.