Bay 12 Games Forum

Ok found some time during lunch to write out this reply.

Yeah, I asked more than one question, most of which hadn't been asked of you before, which as Toaster pointed out you dodged.  And if I can force a slipup by asking a question redundantly, well then, that's not so pointless is it?

Toaster said I dodged the question so I went back and answered it.

He already did show up and defend himself, which you probably would've noticed if you hadn't been lurking yourself.  How exactly did that sequence of events convince you he was noobscum and Dsarker was noobtown, anyway?
Besides that, no matter how good or bad your reasons are, you shouldn't be sitting on them from the beginning of D1 to halfway through D2, waiting for the target of a vague suspicion to respond.  Sure, you've started asking questions now, but what were you doing until now?  Sitting on admittedly poor reasons, doing nothing, and generally being useless to the town!

He didn't defend himself! He just showed up made a post about how he wasn't scum then left. In no way did he discredit my attack. He made a post on page 9 didn't post again till page 15. He basically said he wasn't answering any questions because he was afraid of getting lynched. The only people who are afraid of being lynched are scum! If he doesn't come out and help scumhunt then he's giving the victory over to the scum. So far that is the scummiest thing anyone has done so far so thats why my vote is still on him.


Yeah I am asking questions now, and you know why? because no one else is doing it. Everyone is waiting for another person to step up and make a case against a scum. Well the scum ain't going to show themselves unless we do something about it. We are all like Marines in a landing craft storming a beach. Yeah the first one off is likely to get shot but unless someone does it we are all going to get killed. I understand why it can seem scummy for me to all of a sudden be posting but unless we do something as the town we won't make it. Just don't shoot me in the back solely for trying, because that is a scummy thing to do.


Caz You gotta join in with the rest of us and help hunt scum.

Shoes, Toaster and Drakon please fill us in on your opinions.

I'm going to request an Extend as i'm wiring up my house and don't have time to post a full reply until tommorow or late tonight

You didn't answer my question, and I'm pretty sure we're using different definitions of "redundant".

We could be, i'm using it in the sense that if i've already answered the question asking me it again is pointless.

Ignore?  Would you ignore questions directed at you with a FoS based on a perceived lack of "conviction"?  Or maybe you'd only notice if I voted for you instead of Caz, seeing as my only ability as town is going to waste.

I might, or I might slouch it off. Right now there is nobody voting except for me and Caz. Why would Caz feel any pressure to answer your questions unless you were voting for him? Its night in about a day. Make him or someone else feel pressured otherwise we as town are screwed.

Again, you didn't answer my question.  I'm so glad you had evidence on Drakon.  Would you care to share it with the rest of the class?

I had already stated my opinion and my reasons. To reiterate, during the RVS dsarker asked drakon a few questions and drakon freaked out, voted dsarker then started lurking.

Is that incredibly scummy? no but its the best lead I have and i'm going to continue to vote drakon until he shows up and defends himself.

Shark where are you? who do you suspect?

I've had ostrich.

It was tasty

Quote from: Andrew425 on October 29, 2011, 04:29:37 pm

Remalle, why don't you throw a vote at Caz if you suspect him? Are you just soft balling your teammate?

Because the day had just started.  There's still plenty of time to vote him AFTER I collect enough evidence against him (er, or so I assume.  I'm not actually sure when the day ends, but I guess there's at least twenty-four hours left?).
How about you, Andrew?  Trying to call both scum at once, diverting all suspicion from yourself?  Trying to get me to vote for someone that's not you?  What were you doing on D1, anyway?  I seem to recall you random voting Drakon at first and then doing nothing for the rest of the day.

Why are you acting so defensive? It was a simple question

So then drakon who do you currently suspect and why?

I had a great time learning from you guys