There is no concrete there. It's like if I just randomly picked an egg because I liked it and the rest would all be broken. And I kept doing that with no pattern.
You're putting words in my mouth. Where the hell are you getting "no pattern" from my description? The part where I don't specifically describe the qualities required for a "good cog," which should be obvious from the description?
And you're ignoring all the gods and such who could conceivably make their own afterlives and there is nothing Heaven can do to stop it since none of their cogs would help.
You're ignoring the fact that heaven is working for the gods. It's a bit like complaining about government because each state can't make their own national bureaucracy. Not to mention that the original idea was that the Gods of Heaven were overgods, Shys'm Caes and the like, while the others were simply (relatively) powerless late-comers. After all, why would the folks who set up reality just happen to care so much about humans?
And, as it happens, under the system you promote,
gods still can't create
People being able to choose where they end up unconsciously is interesting...
No, it really isn't. It's a non-answer, and it's also horribly cliche. One of the biggest cliches, a major cop-out used by nearly every single fantasy sink and many non-fantasy sinks. It's the same old, same old. At least try to use a less-overused cliche and put a spin on that, rather than taking an un-spinnable major cliche!
and most of all, SOMETHING THE MAJORITY OF THE PLAYERS LIKE BETTER.
When did you become a majority?
No one has to yield to you. And please, do show me where Scapheap approved it.
Again, this was before we had everyone trying to cram their lore into their small packages. scapheap never needed to approve anything. Show where he approved of Aedan, or of Anima being Isis, or of any of this other crap that's been around since his days. So, basically you're asking for the Social Security number of someone born before that was a thing.
Sure. Who likes GWG's afterlife better than the one we have agreed upon.
No, we didn't agree on it. And if the fucking multiverse can go
completely against established precedent whenever we like it...well, what's the point?
