39601
Forum Games and Roleplaying / Re: The Shaping of the Formless Void OOC
« on: December 28, 2012, 08:19:06 pm »Well, it's not quite the most accurate comparison, but it is a good game. I first played Phantom inside Starcraft 2; I don't know where else it's been.So, like Diplomacy?
It's a game of diplomacy and betrayal, and it usually starts like this, with some unsteady alliances, before everyone reveals their hidden agendas and goes for the neck.
1. You can't take energy from the past because it was all used. If you take some then our current universe would drastically change in unknown ways.It was not used, and many-world theory.
Quote
2. Sure, you could expand spacetime withing the barriers but you would need energy to do so which would run out in an enclosed space. But no, creativity and control over space and time can't let you do anything. You try to step out of bounds, i will put your physics raping ass back in line. Imagine you are in a room and the room is defined by 4 walls, a ceiling, and a floor. You have complete control over what happens in the room and the volume of the room and whatnot, but the room is still defined by the walls, so you cant change them.I highly doubt you have the power to do that, but if that happens I'll figure something out.
Quote
3. If you say the many universes theory is true within this game then that makes Xantalos the most powerful god in existence. He could merge another universe with this one and alter the balance of power. He could merge us with a universe where it is pure madness creatures everywhere or pure dragons or pure liquid. That allows for too much asspulling "Oh, the Riftborn is eating everything. I'll just merge us with a universe that has the anti-riftborn! Problem solved, no conflict. Ponies for all!". Which would be dumb. NO ALTERNATE UNIVERSES IN THIS GAME.1. That assumes you can actually do that. The definition of "universe" is typically "nothing elsewhere can affect it." Xantalos is only in this universe.
2. You're assuming that a god of barriers can force us to go to another universe, which is preposterous.
3. You're assuming that Xantalos WOULD follow your insane troll logic (logic of an insane troll, not insane logic of a troll).
4. You're assuming that the GM would accept that ITL.
5. You're assuming that what you see as a bad story device stops something from actually being true. Guess what? There's a lot of stuff IRL that makes for a worse "story," but it's still true.
The "many universes" theory is grounded in modern science, but might be best ignored for game reasons. And while I don't agree with my colleague on every level, his point is somewhat sound, and I think that conservation of energy is a very important gameplay element that will drive the stories's conflict--by forcing us into diplomacy, or outright war. GWG and Jbg97 have chosen war; indeed, I see this becoming very central to our plot, if you all are fine with that. But, remember we are all nearly equal in power. A war may be won by the unvocal minority rather than the more story-central majority.1. I created time; barring GM fiat, what I say about time probably goes.
2. Speaking of war...there are three things which determine power in this game: actions, spheres, and restrictions. You have two people on your impromptu alliance; we have at least three. That gives us more actions and a wider range of spheres to get bonuses from. On a related note, a faction trying to eat the universe will have a harder time making friends than one going against them; therefore, unaffiliated parties (e.g. Xantalos) will be more easily convinced to go with us than you, for entirely pragmatic reasons like not getting omnomnomed. Finally, one of your two is stuck in a Time Prison which I keep reinforcing. I'm not certain of victory, but I certainly have a better chance of it.