40516
DF Suggestions / Re: Fort Standard Bearer, and Dwarven Horns
« on: December 18, 2012, 07:25:34 pm »First off, how do you fight while drumming? Second off, when a group gets large enough, organization is worth a fraction of a percent of your forces.Also having one or two dwarfs in a squad of 10 not fighting 100% seems like a waste. Few players have a military bigger than 60 and many new players seem to have trouble getting started with the military as it is.Very true, so why have them not fighting? In any size battle, 10 or 100. Horns can be used then put down or clipped to the belt, backpack etc. Some instruments or battle standards can even be used -as- weapons, polearms, hammers etc, I quite like the idea of horns that act as small dagger weapons or blunt weapons on their underside, seems economical. If not most instruments can be held in one hand for example, allowing a sword or axe to be used and the instrument to be used as a weak shield.
We will get huge off-fort battles at some point, with possibly hundreds of participants, and though I have no idea how this is going to be handled, I can definitely see standards and war drums playing a role in that. Also Officers, which are already in the game, but don't do anything at the moment, even if you get them. (AFAIK there is no way to get a Captain or Lieutenant in world gen and Generals can only migrate to your fort if married to the monarch.)
I don't think it likely even in the civil war times that if someone playing the drums was engaged, they would sit there playing the drums while being hacked to bits.
Quote
Okay, poorly-phrased.In small-scale conflicts, organization is at best a minor advantage.I don't think any military trained personnel alive would agree with this statementI cannot either.
In conflicts of a few dozen people, almost no advantage can be derived from having a drummer or standard-bearer or something.
Quote
Though i've repeated many times above, less about organisation, more about moral or shock value. Even if its just something goblin raiders employ as they attack.Yes, flags are so scary...
I can easily imagine scarier things goblins could have than standards and drums. Like dead babies, or fire, or goblins.
I cannot either.