And how do we feed and equip that army?
1) Looting
2) there are many ways to trade outside towns, from black markets to night creature traders
3) don't freeing one ghost and force it to make weapons
1. Good luck. They're an army, we're not.
2. What makes you think that the black marketers would like us more than normal humans do, and how many night creatures have access to good gear?
3. And how do you get the metal and fuel?
Um, couldn't we give the gift to someone who isn't so useful without conversion? Say, an elf?
Almost any elf? Well, almost any elf without Y chromosomes, of course.
It was an example.
And you really think that daughter of a wizard = almost any elf?
For what purpose? For natural magic, probably. However, Alice+Elf>Alice. Simple math.
Again, Alice has much utility that would be lost if we converted her.
Pfff...
Just a short list:
Advantages of Alice staying human ( as you call that - utility)
1) We may send her in towns for trading ( forest girl is surely a magnificent trader)
2) She may spy ( We have no other options, like a guy with camouflaged body and stealth skill and or a girl that can send animal spies )
Advantages of Alice becoming a night troll
1) She will be more loyal ( I don't want to see her falling deeply in love with some chick and leaving us)
2) She will be stronger
3) She will be tougher
4) Foghorn will lose chance to take her back and marry to someone else (except he finds a husband for a night troll)
5) She will piss Gwen way way less
6) We'll get a powerful fat]
her in law
Well, let's look over those purported advantages...
1. She literally owes her life to us. She was fine with us converting her and glad when we didn't. Unless someone enchants her, not much to worry about there.
2,3. Sure. Let's send our best friend and one of our most powerful allies into danger, rather than someone more expendable...
4. True, but not of much use, as Alice would probably run off rather than get married against her will. Especially if we granted her asylum.
5. I wouldn't bet on it. It seems to be more a personality clash/elf vs. human thing than a "She's not a night creature" thing.
6. A disadvantage, as Foghorn has never consented to us converting her, except in a fit of anger that may well have been sarcasm.
Will you keep saying that converting Alice achieves nothing?
I have never said that.
Dude, never underestimate diplomacy.
I do not underestimate diplomacy, but I prefer to not negotiate with prey. It's disgusting
They're not prey, and even if they were, it's better to negotiate with them than to not have everything we need, neh?
You still haven't explained how NC Alice>Human Alice+other night creature.
Anyways, yay update.
Vote to not convert Alice now, and to ask Illuem what he needs for his artifact.
+1, more magic is always good. Maybe ask what his smithing specialty was in life.