50416
DF Suggestions / Re: Chain pumps
« on: August 01, 2012, 08:42:56 pm »
Alright, let me rephrase my issue:
I'm a bit fuzzy on why the chain pump would be practically different from a screw pump. The both move water, and Wikipedia doesn't explain why the chain pump would be a lot bigger, clunkier, more expensive, and less efficient at moving water.
For that matter...Why would anyone BUILD the chain pump you described? A screw pump can be made from 3 logs; a chain pump as you described it would take 3 stones and a log and cloth for every z-level. Okay, I'm starting to realize that you're thinking that chain pumps would replace pump stacks, but you didn't explain that very well.
"Ya know," your suggestion only came to the part I look at (i.e. the part which has suggestions I probably haven't seen and that the OP remembers clearly) recently, and, again...
I'm a bit fuzzy on why the chain pump would be practically different from a screw pump. The both move water, and Wikipedia doesn't explain why the chain pump would be a lot bigger, clunkier, more expensive, and less efficient at moving water.
For that matter...Why would anyone BUILD the chain pump you described? A screw pump can be made from 3 logs; a chain pump as you described it would take 3 stones and a log and cloth for every z-level. Okay, I'm starting to realize that you're thinking that chain pumps would replace pump stacks, but you didn't explain that very well.
"Ya know," your suggestion only came to the part I look at (i.e. the part which has suggestions I probably haven't seen and that the OP remembers clearly) recently, and, again...
Yes I know this has been suggested before, but my specifics are different and the board threwup a warning message not to necro threads.FYI, necros are AOK and, in theory, SOP in the Suggestions subforum.
i think we should have creeper adventure mode now