Bay 12 Games Forum

It'll still take a while for players to join, took a few weeks for me to get enough folks for the previous one.

You might want to get some names on the replacement list, too, as I required four in BM LX.

Well we wasted a lynch 'cause he failed to mention he could revive, plus the various things I thought he was scummy for.

Only thing I can think of that Reyn would claim scum for when they're not would be a Jester, or a hostile TP with something like Paranoid Gun Owner, or a double bluff.

The claim would encourage people to vote for them, thus fulfilling the Jester's wincon, or for people to act on them during the night, allowing maximum carnage. Neither seems a particularly winning thing to do for scum on D1, so it seemed unlikely to have been a double bluff.

I targeted FoU with a kill last night, though I will repeat that my actions have a 50% chance of failure. Plus the anarchy thing. What information do you get?

Also curious what people think regarding the "Mafia Goon" role name for Reyn. Role names, at least for town, appear to be based on what roles they have, rather than alignment...

"I also propose that every tick one god disc serves as primary influence on communal space.  So if the war god disc is the primary,  the war chance is likely to increase on the communal space. Perhaps each god could describe his discs effects. Maybe the god discs could serve as sources for communal disc magic.

Oppose

I'd say it seems likely that Reyn targeted FoU and got killed by reflection, going by the flavor of FoU's last ability.

Only if it was an auto, which it doesn't appear to be from a perusal of the list. If I killed FoU, someone else killed Reyn.

---

TWS

Unvote

We should probably lynch Reyn sometime (or somebody vig him?) but lynching him is bad for the same reason a D1 nolynch is bad.

Hector: Why were you so worried about Filipk tying the vote when there were still ~16 hours left in the day?

I wasn't worried about that so much, more that it conflicted with what he had said earlier:

Quote from: ReynTheLord on October 27, 2016, 02:06:53 pm

I vote for NO LYNCH

This is by far the worst thing we can do aside from lynching a Jester.  It gives us no new information to work with day 2.

His vote on Reyn made it a situation in which no-one would be lynched. As well as voting for a claimed TP:

Quote from: hector13 on October 27, 2016, 09:10:23 pm

Also, why are you voting for a claimed third-party?

Instead of voting for FoU who I'm not convinced is scum?  Yeah I'll get on Reyn.  I'm willing to back off Reyn this day to get a lynch.  But I'll pick this back up the next day, at least until I get specifics on his wincon.  Unvote.

He may not have thought FoU was scum, but what does getting ridding of a TP do? No closer to finding scum in that instance, and he removed his vote from Reyn despite the reservations regarding FoU, putting FoU back as the lynchee.

fillipk: could you respond to these points?

I tried to kill him.

My actions have a 50% chance of failure though... may have been someone else that actually did the deed.

I'm not sure scum would've done it though, given he was the lynch target from D1; still would've had some suspicion on him.

Oppose discs for all the gods, and celestial souls.

"Except it's a very functional thing to be arguing about, what our seas are made of."

"We're gods, so not really."