Bay 12 Games Forum

You did give the bomb to Starver last night, aye?

I don't think it's the case that Starver is scum. Town wincons have generally been "eliminate the Evil role" so... he must've been the bomb dude, seeing as we don't have one right now. Game would be over if he was scum. Probably.

I'm not sure if not saying things is good. Unless you can't think of anything to ask. Just means you have to decide who to shoot.

Please don't make it as painfully long as D1

As I said, I've told you everything about my role. I could only speculate about what happens when I die (lynches come back probably)

And yes, I am quite certain I am not "Arms Dealer". I only have one action, which is to arm someone with a gun.

You didn't "essentially give TBF the kill", you fool. You killed someone, and then TBF handed the bomb off to someone else. You took away the ability for the town to stop a kill.

I also note you failed to answer any of my questions, Urist McDodger.

What contradictions have you seen?

I've told you everything about my role that I can, anyway, short of directly quoting my PM.

Mmm... Not sure, your argument seems a bit flimsy.

What I'm going for is that he accepted FoU's claim as Town Weakness, but shot him anyway. Why would he shoot someone he accepts as town as a town player?

Even if he didn't accept it as Town Weakness, FoU claimed to get rid of all items he got, including bombs, and Moonlit stated a desire to keep you alive. But shot him anyway. Why would he shoot someone who could conceivably stop another player dying as a town player?

He also said he was deciding between Starver and myself... So why is he shooting FoU?

Obviously I'm a bit biased in this, though, so take the analysis with a pinch of salt.

Question: Have we had a role name called Gunsmith before?

Because I knew that there were street guys. Also it made sense - remember, I'm the blackmailer.

I need to sleep now D:

You said that accepted FoU's claim because you were constantly looking down on the poor, not because you were the blackmailer. So what about his claim was believable?

My role name is Gunsmith, byraway.

Also, either side can still win in a 2-player depending on who has the gun.  So hector, why are you saying that whoever wins wins today?

I can't give the gun to myself, and I can't choose to not arm someone. I assume if I'm dead the gun is out of play, too (Tomasque would have to confirm that, if he wants) so scum win if they're not hit today.

At least that's been the situation in previous rounds. Equal number scum and town result in scum winning.