Bay 12 Games Forum

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Advanced search  

Show Posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.

Messages - hector13

Pages: 1 ... 151 152 [153] 154 155 ... 1297
2281
So I’m expected expected to believe that Lenglon is Neutral, town-ally, who seems to think Max is Neutral, survivor, who seems to think KW is Neutral, baddie.

2282
It’s FoU in MafiaKart all over.

2283
Could it also be that the mafia killed Persus who is just an Evil third-party here?

I don’t like the way Lenglon was acting around Max’s slot on D1, suggesting he was a third-party out of nowhere, then adding another person into the tie near day end which included Max. Questions would arise in a two-way tie over why the survivor wasn’t killed, putting Max under the spotlight during the night and next day, less so in a 3-way tie. You telegraphed that you were going to vote Tric, but Tric was being townread by lots of people so there’s no guarantee they accept a Tric lynch so easily and not just tie the votes up again.

Now she seems bothered that NQT has monster tags, even though she claimed monster tags as Neutral, and Max claimed monster tags and she thinks he’s a survivor, so I’m not sure why NQT’s unclaimed monster tags are such a bother, except possibly in light of 4mask’s claim he interacts with scum monster abilities in some way. Given that at least Lenglon was townread by 4mask for claiming that, there’s no reason for scum!NQT with monster tags not to claim to get town-cred, but that’s a bit WIFOM.

Given the kill flavour, I’m at least convinced it wasn’t a monster type kill, but scum died soooo… yeah.



Absolutely not happy about EJ’s vote, and also not sure why Vector acknowledged Tric’s meta of acting scummy as town, which is exactly what he was doing, and was voting him anyway.

Equally so, Jim thinking Max wasn’t scum because of his meta, despite all the inconsistencies in Max’s behaviour, but was happy to vote Tric despite him following his own town meta.

PPE: should probably post piecemeal instead of trying to get all my thoughts in one post, there’s a lot to posts I haven’t read.

2284
then proceed to push with mobilized to capture what is left after nuclear strikes.

Remember the time Russia occupied Chernobyl? Remember when its soldiers were playing around in the Red Forest, the notoriously highly irradiated forest that came about some years after the disaster? Remember how they were making trenches in the highly irradiated parts in the exclusion zone?

Yeah.. Russia has NO strategic depth or knowledge on how to do military operations with territory that has irradiated terrain/environments.

Russia has NO strategic depth or knowledge on how to do military operations. Period

It still conducts them. Besides, no one cares, even in Russia, if Russian soldiers will die.

I see no other logical explanation of this referendums circus, other than a thin excuse for using nuclear weapons. Sure, Russia did many illogical steps in this war and it may be one of them.

Nobody outside of Ukraine gave much of a shit about Crimea being annexed in 2014. Russia is probably hoping the same thing happens here when the referendum shows that citizens totally weren’t forced or intimidated by armed soldiers at their door to vote for annexation. The nuclear threat is presumably to stop Ukraine from trying to take these territories back.

2285
General Discussion / Re: Things that made you go "WTF?" today o_O
« on: September 24, 2022, 10:40:55 am »
Stellaris was hard to play for me because I always tried to be the xenophobic human style civilization but I can't actually play evil in any game for any extended period of time so all those playthroughs just petered out.

Maybe I should install it again and see what how it's changed over the years now that CK3 might not be the next CK2.
I by and large cant do worst endings in rpgs.
I rather enjoyed my genocide run in Undertale.

2286
Mafia / Re: Webadict's Supernatural - Day 1: The Burning Sun [13 / 13]
« on: September 23, 2022, 09:57:20 pm »
Don’t put it in the scum’s hands. I don’t like either other option.

2287
Mafia / Re: Webadict's Supernatural - Day 1: The Burning Sun [13 / 13]
« on: September 23, 2022, 09:56:42 pm »
There’s still a 67% chance of not dying in a tie.

Town’s weapon though guys.

2288
Mafia / Re: Webadict's Supernatural - Day 1: The Burning Sun [13 / 13]
« on: September 23, 2022, 09:54:07 pm »
Excuse me?

2289
Mafia / Re: Webadict's Supernatural - Day 1: The Burning Sun [13 / 13]
« on: September 23, 2022, 09:47:58 pm »
I am not a fan of either candidate right now.

Why is Tric a candidate anyway?

2290
Mafia / Re: Webadict's Supernatural - Day 1: The Burning Sun [13 / 13]
« on: September 23, 2022, 06:14:39 pm »
Also EJ what the shit you have plenty time to look into me.

If you don’t want to go through the 30+ pages of thread, go to search function for the forum a couple of tabs to the left of the “my messages” tab, put Supernatural in the search bar, sorted by recent posts, my name in the user bar, and you probably don’t even need to limit it to the mafia subforum but do it anyway. I just did it and it lists all my posts in the game on the first page, which is good ‘cause I think it breaks if you try to go to page 2.

I don’t mind the vote, but I’d like a better reason than “fuck it” :p

2291
Mafia / Re: Webadict's Supernatural - Day 1: The Burning Sun [13 / 13]
« on: September 23, 2022, 06:05:03 pm »
You make a fair point there Jim.

I don’t like the point though :(

Spoiler: bananas speculation (click to show/hide)

Not rightly sure how to approach the voting nonsense as me unvoting Max and voting my second choice of 4mask ties the vote.

Unvote, I suppose.

2292
Mafia / Re: Webadict's Supernatural - Day 1: The Burning Sun [13 / 13]
« on: September 23, 2022, 05:29:04 pm »
@Persus

I’m later to comment on events in the game than most, sure, ‘cause of the coasting, and I’m working with the same information that everyone else is, so it shouldn’t really be that surprising I’m drawing the same conclusions as other players.

I don’t really know what you’re expecting me to do. If I don’t have anything novel to say should I just be silent and/or not vote?

@Vector

My preference would be for a Max elimination, but I’m not averse to a 4mask one either, as I would hope my recent posts have made clear.

Jim made a summary of Max’s play (that I’ll link in a different post ‘cause of a current distraction) that adequately describes a significant portion of why I like Max as scum, Max has dropped quite a few votes today which is absolutely not something he tends to do, and he delegated his vote to Jim, even though he at one point suggested to Jim he didn’t trust him, plus trying to keep himself off the block shifting to voting NQT, who I currently read as town.

2293
General Discussion / Re: Things that made you go "WTF?" today o_O
« on: September 23, 2022, 12:57:59 pm »
This is good. At least you’re on the road to getting things right, and you’re doing it together.

2294
Mafia / Re: Webadict's Supernatural - Day 1: The Burning Sun [13 / 13]
« on: September 23, 2022, 12:54:13 pm »
@Persus, another person making it hard for me to clip quotes on my phone

I get the coasting thing, ‘cause I am, for the various reasons I think I outlined at the top of my reads list.

As fer 4mask, it was this post I was referring to with the sheeping thing. He also seems to have spent a lot of time reading games other than this one to get a handle on Tric, which is an awful lot of effort for very little payoff (the possibility of solving one slot on D1 in a 13 player game). I could argue that makes it look like he’s making an effort when he really isn’t, but I’d rather have a Max elimination at this time.

Lenglon favouring NQT over 4mask also raised a point against 4mask, namely that 4mask hasn’t voted after 2 early RVS efforts, and a vote on Tric two posts after the one I linked, at that point based on sheeping and a bizarro scumtell in the post between the vote and the linked one. I’m used to seeing 4mask throw his vote around like it’s going out of fashion. I will concede I’ve not played a game with him for a while, but it doesn’t sit well.

Continuing on from something I said earlier, that the town’s weapon against hostile parties is voting them out, obviously that means a townie’s vote is important. Max thus delegating his vote to someone else does not reflect well on him, and 4mask parking their vote on Tric for sheepy/bizarre reasons while they go out of thread to figure them out is also a bit of a weird one.

Anyway… that’s another thing that got away from me heh.

As for EJ, I think I said at the end of my read in him that I could be wrong, I’m just kind of unwilling to scumread someone (on D1) for making a good effort to push the game forward, even if it’s against their meta a little bit. He might very well have phases of paranoia as scum - I’ve been playing mafia for years and I get waves like that as both alignments - but I would probably expect that to manifest itself in the scum thread if he has one available rather than the game thread. I’m not sure how easy it would be to fake paranoia realistically.

Anyway, even thinking of it like that, there are other people I would prefer to see flip instead of EJ right now. I think in the views of other people, you and I are probably on that list :p

Also, you seem to have set aside a part for Toony in that big post, but there’s nothing in it.

2295
Mafia / Re: Webadict's Supernatural - Day 1: The Burning Sun [13 / 13]
« on: September 23, 2022, 11:29:58 am »
If I had to take a wild guess here and now? I'd guess three witches, one good one neutral one evil, some kind of witch hunter that wants to find witches instead of evils, some kind of non-monster SK, and three monster-themed mafia. I think from Web's perspective and game balance I was treated as a town miller instead of as a 3p. But it's a D1 in a 13 player Web game, I don't think speculating on the setup composition is going to be productive, and I'm unconcerned with it when I'm attempting to figure people out right now. I'll probably be more interested in this topic on later days, just not now.

Well that’s the thing though, is you seem to think Max is a neutral survivor so it would make sense for me to question.your thoughts on the distribution, to see how he might fit in to that.

‘cause I don’t rightly understand the jump to immediately suspecting Max of being a survivor instead of just trying to retcon his reasons for a vote to make it seem a bit more reasonable, particularly in the face of tying up his wagon with NQT’s. He could do that as scum or town, really, so why the jump to survivor?

Pages: 1 ... 151 152 [153] 154 155 ... 1297