Bay 12 Games Forum

Lenglon, why inspect MS again when it didn't work the first time?

We don’t actually know it didn’t work, since if it hit Esteemed Jim Groovester and Esteemed BlackHeartKabal. If it did we would expect a double “yes group chat” result, as opposed to one yes and one no.

My assumption is, given Esteemed Lenglon was marked for death, Esteemed BlackHeartKabal was one of the players hit.

What does being immune to protects mean?

No idea, I never asked.

PPE: pretty sure the restriction has already been broken, but I’ll ask Most Esteemed FallacyofUrist just in case.

Esteemed BlackHeartKabal died with a bomb.  We don't see evidence of that in the roleflip.  Should we?

I don’t know if you are familiar with the character Mrs. Doyle from Father Ted, but I will channel her essence should you not break the restriction, because you have absolutely no reason not to.

While I'm on the subject, Esteemed Imp could be scum even if Esteemed ToonyMan is telling the truth, both with or without the possibility of having been role-changed (if Warehouse 13 is also unable to lose abilities, all that would be swapped would be the names. I don't know much about that show, but it seems sort of plausible that Warehouse 13 might gain abilities and never lose them, actually.)

---

Esteemed hector13, re: your comment to Esteemed Imp, let me specify that I'm willing to intentionally break the restriction if people think it's better. My protect is probably less worthwhile as the game wears on anyway.

I didn’t ask Most Esteemed FallacyofUrist anything about the restriction beyond how strict it was at game start and if I could use pronouns.

You are either throwing your entire team under the bus, a very lucky SK, or you’re town, and I’m pretty sure you broke the restriction yesterday so I’m happy to consider it the latter for the time being.

I tell a lie the explanation doesn’t make sense.

You lose nothing breaking the restriction Esteemed Imp, with your new role and your old one, should it still exist in the ether somewhere.

PPE: @Esteemed Maximum Spin yes that’s right you didn’t either, I just forget my thought process while typing on my phone, and also having to put Esteemed before everyone’s name. Also I shouldn’t be playing right now but it’s interesting.

I tried to make Esteemed Imp kill immune; and that was ruined by Esteemed ToonyMan.

Esteemed Imp, I’d feel a lot more comfortable about your slot if you could either break the restriction or give me a very good reason why you’re not.

No idea why I would inspect as anything other than town.

I will say, in Esteemed Lenglon’s defense, Esteemed Maximum Spin didn’t know who Esteemed Lenglon visited, and Esteemed Lenglon claimed to have visited Esteemed Maximum Spin with one action.

Quote from: Elephant Parade on December 31, 2023, 07:02:46 pm

Lenglon, MaximumSpin, any idea why your claims contradicted each other yesterday?

I find it extremely suspicious that Esteemed BlackHeartKabal supposedly inspected as not having a group chat, since Esteemed BlackHeartKabal actually was mafia, but it's hard for me to see this as a gambit when it did result in finding and killing mafia.

The implication being we were wrong about the combination of who Esteemed Lenglon visited, or you being bussed with Esteemed Jim Groovester.

PPE: no secrets with the auto I gave you Esteemed Jim Groovester, it does exactly what it says on the tin.

The fact Esteemed Imp is sticking to it bothers me.

Cool beans, I’ll just go back to

Esteemed BlackHeartKabal then.