Bay 12 Games Forum

Quote from: fillipk on February 07, 2017, 02:20:39 am

Quote from: doll on February 07, 2017, 02:19:06 am

I'm actually an alien survivor.
I can only assume you're scum from your behavior.
What tech do you want me to pick to help us for the game end?
Like I said I was thinking holdout blaster for it's tech-swapping options for lynches.

I'm not scum, but I won't lynch you or reveal you at all, as you said the town loses out.

It would still benefit town to be aware of this and the fact that A) a scumsiding role is in the game B) a scumsiding role has small tech and C) I'm a great option for ass drones and tech shielded/guardianed vig's etc.

Quote from: webadict on February 07, 2017, 03:05:11 pm

So much hostility.

Sheesh, I don't actually want doll lynched. I'd rather lynch hector13. Or fillipk. Probs both.

Doll's still getting used to having marionette control on the game. I have practiced my webweaving much more, so we'll see how it goes.

Oh and TBF, I answered your question.

I'll answer a few more later.

So you don't want Doll lynched so they can practice influencing everything in the game?  Seems like a shitty reason to me.  I am in agreement with Leafsnail here that lying is almost always bad for the town.

As Doll said Scum has information because they know who isn't scum and thus they know everyone against them.
Town does not have information and thus needs to get good information quickly.
Spreading fake claims doesn't help town get good information and these wild fakeclaims don't reduce the quality of information scum has since you are still against them and since they can't verify if any of this is true till the first night it doesn't help town day 1.
Plus your lying a lot and really town has almost no reason to lie. Anti-information is anti town and yes I would prefer to lynch a scum player then an anti-town but I put anti-town above random lynch.

I also find it weird how webadict is covering for Doll and echoing the, "I think Fillipk is scummy" sentiment of Doll.  I could be wrong though.

I don't understand the hate for Hector13, he's going after TheBiggerFish who has been in a decent amount of games and should realize that this behavior isn't accepted here.  Even if he is posting from phone there are post numbers or he could just post less, but more meaningful content which is always an option.

Quote from: Leafsnail on February 07, 2017, 08:31:51 pm

Since you're shitting nonsense claims everywhere (Survivor and Exterminator are mutually exclusive with each other and kook) it's impossible to tell whether you're being serious or not with your kook claim. Knowing whether each player is claiming kook or not is beneficial to the town because it means any Agents can aim away from them. It also gives the mafia no relevant role information because the "kook" modifier can be applied to any town role. So why are you muddying the waters on this issue? I have two explanations.
1. You are mafia or some third party, and you are trying to undermine kook claims in order to make any town Agents weaker and give yourself an out if you're investigated later.
2. You are stirring shit for no reason at all, without considering whether it's beneficial to your win condition. I have no problem lynching someone like this.

Also, Wubba, this is the crux of the case against Doll.  I agree with this basically 100% and don't have anything meaningful to add so going after Doll is akin to bandwagoning.  Same can be said of TBF, that's why I'm not voting TBF, just letting people know where I stand on both issues and, if it came down to it, who I would vote for.