I agree with the lot of what you are saying... but open sourcing DF... I think no one has the right to tell toady to do that he made the game and just because its popular doesn’t mean it's our game, he made DF and he has spent 5 years on the game so you have no right to tell toady to open source a game, I think open sourcing ruins games as any person can edit a master peace, it's like giving a marker to a 5 year old and telling him to make the Mona Lisa "better".
Suggesting ways to improve the game is what this part of the forums is for. That includes suggestions such as opening the source. Nobody is trying to make Toady do anything, we are explaining why open sourcing the game would improve both the game and his experience as the developer.