361
General Discussion / Re: Conspiracy Theories: The Reread The Civility Clause Thread
« on: September 20, 2020, 06:55:36 pm »
> The catholic church was coming to execute all the masons in Europe
Where is this stuff coming from?
So the ... masons headed west from Europe in the middle ages, that's the conspiracy theory. Presumably this is a Mormon-type thing where they landed in the USA. But here's a sanity check on that claim. The claim is that boatloads of masons escaped to the Americas. Why, then, didn't they build any masonry when they got there? If you tell me to look at the Aztecs or Incas you should bitch-slap whoever told you that. The whole point about native American architecture is how wacky it is, since it developed in isolation from Eurasian architecture. They had some novel building techniques that the Old World doesn't have, but they also lacked basic things like wheeled vehicles to transport materials, or basic architecture like arches.
> Aside from these people, and say, the Vikings who mysteriously disappeared, is there any other indigenous or non-indigenous groups who are rumored to, or have officially, had to make mass migrations in the past? Also what is the actual likely story behind the Vikings disappearing?
This is at the level where all I can say is you should read the whole wikipedia entry on the vikings before we can even discuss that.
Nobody disappeared, the vikings are the ancestors of the Danes, Swedes, Norwegians. Iceland is one of the remaining Viking outposts, and it's kind of obvious they're related to modern people in Scandinavia. What happened was that at the start there weren't big centralized kingdoms in Scandinavia so local lords would send raiding parties out, but as they conquered territory and Scandinavia consolidated into a few larger kingdoms, this behavior died out.
Where is this stuff coming from?
So the ... masons headed west from Europe in the middle ages, that's the conspiracy theory. Presumably this is a Mormon-type thing where they landed in the USA. But here's a sanity check on that claim. The claim is that boatloads of masons escaped to the Americas. Why, then, didn't they build any masonry when they got there? If you tell me to look at the Aztecs or Incas you should bitch-slap whoever told you that. The whole point about native American architecture is how wacky it is, since it developed in isolation from Eurasian architecture. They had some novel building techniques that the Old World doesn't have, but they also lacked basic things like wheeled vehicles to transport materials, or basic architecture like arches.
> Aside from these people, and say, the Vikings who mysteriously disappeared, is there any other indigenous or non-indigenous groups who are rumored to, or have officially, had to make mass migrations in the past? Also what is the actual likely story behind the Vikings disappearing?
This is at the level where all I can say is you should read the whole wikipedia entry on the vikings before we can even discuss that.
Quote
Expert sailors and navigators aboard their characteristic longships, Vikings voyaged as far as the Mediterranean littoral, North Africa, and the Middle East. After decades of exploration around the coasts and rivers of Europe, Vikings established Norse communities and governments scattered across north-western Europe, Belarus,[9] Ukraine[10] and European Russia, the North Atlantic islands all the way to the north-eastern coast of North America. The Vikings and their descendants established themselves as rulers and nobility in many areas of Europe. The Normans, descendants of Vikings who conquered and gave their name to what is now Normandy, also formed the aristocracy of England after the Norman conquest of England. While spreading Norse culture to foreign lands, they simultaneously brought home strong foreign cultural influences to Scandinavia, profoundly influencing the historical development of both. During the Viking Age the Norse homelands were gradually consolidated from smaller kingdoms into three larger kingdoms; Denmark, Norway and Sweden.
Nobody disappeared, the vikings are the ancestors of the Danes, Swedes, Norwegians. Iceland is one of the remaining Viking outposts, and it's kind of obvious they're related to modern people in Scandinavia. What happened was that at the start there weren't big centralized kingdoms in Scandinavia so local lords would send raiding parties out, but as they conquered territory and Scandinavia consolidated into a few larger kingdoms, this behavior died out.