2470
« on: July 29, 2012, 01:41:12 pm »
No need for big introductions, people just seem reluctant with threads started by new people because of the spambots that try to sell their useless crap here.
Generally I don't find it necessary to have an especially skilled broker. After the first few years you usually have way too many items anyway, so it is better to overpay and get rid of stuff than to try to pay a minimum and drown in useless crafts you don't need.
The appraiser skill is raised by performing a trade, you can level the skill to novice by just letting a dwarf trade one item for another. It does not matter wether the trade is sucessful or not, but only opening the window is not enough.
The other skills like judge of intent, negotiator etc that could affect trade (I'm not sure how exactly/if they do at all) are social skills that are raised by idling and socialising with other dwarfs. Since your broker is also your bookkeeper she is probably busy full time and does not socialise much.
So I'd say, if you are a few years in, broker skills don't matter at all, "novice appraiser" is needed to see prices, but you can train any dwarf up to that with a few performed trades.
I have a dedicated broker, but when he is busy/sleeping/on break etc I let anyone trade. The merchants will want to earn about 30-50%, no matter who trades.