Bay 12 Games Forum

Yeah it's not ideal. If Vector dies I am possibly scum fmypov (though by then I will have another dream), while if they don't die then Vector is probably scum (and if they aren't, they can clear me)

I find it pretty funny that your argument to lynch me is literally based on being uncomfirmable when you are uncomfirmable yourself, without the ability to offer any useful information.

Seriously though. Day 4 and your argument for lynching someone is "they're not confirmable" and not understanding association fallacy re: claimed actions.

To note Caz, my role may not be confirmable without someone investigating me, but at least it's not an active role that should return results but never seems to, always promising more and more tomorrow. But it never happens.

The role does what it does. That you think me providing results that end up not being helpful is less believable than providing results that end up being helpful is a problem with your reasoning. Does a lucky dice roll point to town? No. It is a dice roll.

Quote from: Caz on March 08, 2021, 03:53:44 am

I dreamed about Toonyman, who apparently protected me. Which Vector can prove, no?

So you basically got a PM of him putting up wards on your house or something?

They didn't leave their house, they set up a protection spell and then napped in a chair before a figure broke in and caused their insides to combust. It was quite graphic. Definitely killed by magus magic.

Quote from: Caz on March 08, 2021, 04:10:34 am

Quote from: webadict on March 07, 2021, 10:59:13 pm

I do have interesting information. I apparently wasn't blocked. So, I've got juicy information.

IcyTea31 is...

Innocent. IcyTea31 did not do anything suspicious last Night, so that pretty much proves it's not IcyTea31. This means it's Caz or TricMagic.

Also, the flip Yesterday doesn't necessarily point towards a Luckyowl convert, but it does leave Persus13, TricMagic, Vector, or Lucky as the Convert.

WHY wouldn't you check Lucky given that the convert has to do the kill?

Three reasons:

1) BluarianKnight being SK does not immediately confirm Luckyowl is the Convert.
2) If IcyTea31 was the Dark Magus, I assumed they would Super Saint their Convert and I would Follow that.
3) I literally said I would Follow IcyTea Yesterday, and while I did consider Following Lucky as a gambit, I also briefly entertained Following ToonyMan or Vector to prove myself but ultimately realized that ToonyMan is dead 9 times out of 10 and Following Vector wasn't exactly gonna do anything to find scum.

So, yes, I did Follow IcyTea31. They didn't kill anyone. They're not the Convert. I thought that I'd be able to see both, but I didn't consider that the Dark Magus might not be trackable.

1) That's literally the reason why you should have followed Lucky.
2) Why go after the dark magus when it could be several different people and we need to get the convert? Makes no sense.
3) Why would you actually tell us what you're going to do given that the only way I can be cleared is by seeing someone else's action? If everyone's claiming their actions beforehand I could just claim I saw you do what you said you'd do.


This is not a town web.

Okay, so basically your comment is a no-win situation unless I saw Luckyowl do the kill. If I swapped to Luckyowl and saw nothing, you'd be yelling at me for swapping away from IcyTea31. I don't really see this as big of a deal as you seem to.

If you saw Lucky do nothing then we can eliminate them as scum, which is kinda useful since Vector has been telling lies about them. If Lucky is clear, Vector is implicated.

My goal was to remove a potential suspect from both the Dark Magus and the Convert pool.

You did neither. Oops!

It is also entirely possible that I forcibly locked down the Devildeal kill by keeping IcyTea31 at home.

1. You're high if you think there is actually a devildeal kill on the table. It would have been used in the night if it existed, BY LUCKY WHO WAS THE ONLY POSSIBLE PERSON WHO COULD USE IT.

2. Even if there is a devildeal, Icy wouldn't be able to use it.

If y'all want me to Follow Luckyowl, then it's a lot easier to do so when you say so.

Scum web needs a lot of handholding apparently.

1) BluarianKnight being SK does not immediately confirm Luckyowl is the Convert.

So you think LuckyOwl is town now???

So web is either dumb or scum. Cool. Just waiting on Vector to claim doing nothing for teams to be set.

I do have interesting information. I apparently wasn't blocked. So, I've got juicy information.

IcyTea31 is...

Innocent. IcyTea31 did not do anything suspicious last Night, so that pretty much proves it's not IcyTea31. This means it's Caz or TricMagic.

Also, the flip Yesterday doesn't necessarily point towards a Luckyowl convert, but it does leave Persus13, TricMagic, Vector, or Lucky as the Convert.

WHY wouldn't you check Lucky given that the convert has to do the kill?

Also Icy claiming no disturbed graves again. What did you do last night Vector?

I dreamed about Toonyman, who apparently protected me. Which Vector can prove, no?