Well, I figure I might just list the contents of my wishlist. Has anyone played any of these, what did you think, and do you still play them?
These I have played:
Risk of Rain: I call this excellent. There's a demo, iirc, so check that out. Do still fire it up occasionally, though I cheat like a so and so. It's fun. I've probably beat it over a dozen times so far. Couple times even legit

King Arthur's Gold: I think some folks around here like it? I played a little before it was pay or whatever, was kinda' interesting, but too early in the dev cycle to really sink into. No clue what it's like these days.
FATE: Unless there's a second FATE running around, this is basically an old diablo clone with just about everything that entails. More or less the precursor to the torchlight games. It's not terrible, per se, but not something I'd recommend. Aim for torchlight (or TL2) instead. Either are basically FATE but magnitudes better.
Shadowrun Returns*: Eeehhnn... I've got it. It's probably better now, what with player made content, but the original incarnation was less than glorious. Definitely not
bad, but lacking in a certain oomph. It's also pretty low spec. Runs fine on a 2.1 ghz dual core, 4 gig ram, shitty integrated graphics card. Haven't played in a while, though.
Hammerwatch: I really liked this. Never got around to playing multiplayer, unfortunately, which I'd still rather like to do one of these days. If you remember and liked Gauntlet, there's a
very high chance you'd enjoy at least a few hours of this. Definitely fire it up occasionally, though I still haven't sat down and beat it. It's pretty enjoyable.
Revenge of the Titans: Played a little, either a demo or something less than licit, don't remember. Was kinda' interesting, but a bugger to cheat on, which left me less interested

Not a terrible TD, overall.