24751
General Discussion / Re: How do you view the wealthy?
« on: September 07, 2012, 03:27:15 am »Going with the other questions...QuoteHave you ever lived under the poverty level?
Yes.
So, how'd you get out from under it?
What's your sure-fire strategy that other people should use to out from under it? It would seem you believe it is possible with right action for anyone to escape the condition. Perhaps some details?
As the aside, should isn't a particularly imprecise or fuzzy concept. It's just a prescriptive statement indicating best action or rule. When a person says "should", if they're using it in the general sense, they're saying that they find whatever follows to be the most appropriate action or situation, and thus something that is rightfully assumed by other people, i.e. become a rule or law, in other words a universal (at least in relation to the subject in question; the subject can be as large or larger than existent reality or as small or smaller than a single group or person) pattern.
E:As a later note, realized after some idle rumination, LB, your confusion over should statements seeming to be preference statements is likely a very natural confusion -- it is absolutely true that most people would prefer it if the actions prescribed were followed or the situation described organized as such. However, that preference is separate from the prescriptive statement, despite generally accompanying it. It's understandable how you'd conflate the two (and, being fair, prescriptive statements are often misused in an attempt to add greater authority to preference statements), but they are in fact separate things. Perhaps that makes things more clear for you?
E: If you'd really like, I could give a little breakdown morality 101 lesson and provide a more clear picture of exactly where prescriptive statements stand. Be a bit of a derail, but not terribly much effort.