Bay 12 Games Forum

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Advanced search  

Show Posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.

Messages - IcyTea31

Pages: 1 ... 16 17 [18] 19 20 ... 621
256
Mafia / Re: Supernatural 10 - Day 1 begins
« on: February 23, 2021, 01:06:18 pm »
4maskwolf

Also, Icy, your question to web was dumb because... it was dumb? That's really the only way of describing it. Like, what?
Is it dumber than not trying to start any conversation at all?



Toaster

You probably saw this coming.  Did you expect this?
Absolutely. In fact, it would have been most interesting if you'd picked someone else, since then I'd have asked why you picked them in particular. Why did you pick the boring option?



TricMagic

I have no powers, so feel free to come and kill me. Or watch me. Or anything else.
Why would you claim this? What good is it to the town?

And so the run of being scummy continues.
Continues? 4maskwolf hadn't posted anything before his claim?

So you know that post wasn't coached at all given the number of experienced players in this game.
Suspiciously specific.



webadict, ToonyMan

This is true. Web is my Webuddy.
Alright, time to triple down on this investment.
Tripling down on not having a real conversation with each other? Bold move.



notquitethere

I doubt it is separate at all. He probably just means town by that. You tell me, has it ever meant anything else? There's apparently nothing new this time round:
I've only skimmed the past games, so I wouldn't know. How useful is flavour analysis in general in this format? Mephansteras said that it wouldn't be useless.

257
Mafia / Re: Supernatural 10 - Day 1 begins
« on: February 23, 2021, 12:02:28 pm »
Those questions to web and vec are pretty lolworthy. and NQT for that matter.
Elaborate?

258
Mafia / Re: Supernatural 10 - Day 1 begins
« on: February 23, 2021, 11:47:49 am »
webadict: You just called Toony "friend". How is that not buddying?

Vector: Assume you have a daykill. Someone makes a revelation which puts me in a thunderdome with a player you don't have a good read on. Do you shoot me or the other player?

TricMagic: What do you think of the banter other players made before this post?

ToonyMan: What's the point of placing a meme vote without adding your personal touch to it?

BluarianKnight: You're the only one here I haven't played with before. Should I consider you dangerous?

Luckyowl: If you survive to a three-way endgame, how will you decide which of the other players you will vote for?

Secretdorf: What do you think about 4maskwolf's survivor claim?

4maskwolf: Since you suggested a D1 4mask wagon, why aren't you voting for yourself?

Toaster: Could you place your vote, just so I can see you have one? Not going to let that lose me another game.

juicebox: How will you avoid being lynched D2?

Jim Groovester: How can I best convince you to read at least the parts addressed to you if I make lengthier posts?

notquitethere: How likely is it that the "pure of heart" status mentioned in the D1 opening post flavour is separate from being town?

259
Lastelle points the wheelchair spot out for Bowler to stand in and takes a seat herself. She still seems very active, perhaps even anxious, her hands and legs shaking with excitement. Or maybe it's all the energy drinks.

"I don't know, Knuckles, I think it'd be cool if someone had been recording this. I've been on top form tonight. This'll be a great story to tell the next time I want some free drinks."

260
Mafia / Re: Supernatural 10 - SIGNUPS (8/9+)
« on: February 22, 2021, 04:00:46 am »
In.

261
Mafia / Re: Exquisite Cops and Robbers II - Final Night
« on: February 20, 2021, 04:23:22 am »
So mafia won lurking while town disintegrated itself. Post-mortems:

I don't understand at all why Tric self-voted on D1. I can't see any situation where that would have been the correct move, though daykilling me was a good move. After my death, Tric shouldn't have given up but gone after Secretdorf for knowing that they'd lied. Town really didn't have the mislynches to afford losing two townies on D1.

As for the Caz lynch, that was a mess of Caz being confused of whether or not they were blocked and thus "lying" about things I knew were false. I should have noticed the Dead Air, Dead Townie situation when no scumbuddy tried to defend them, but I think I did pretty well in narrowing the scum team to two of Caz, Secretdorf and Toaster. In hindsight, Secretdorf would have been the obvious liar-lynch since I was still waiting for Toaster to confirm whether or not they had used the batman block and lost their vote, which would have confirmed Caz's story of being blocked.

Good job to Toaster on announcing the thunderdome on D1, and Secretdorf for keeping his head down, but I have to admit this was a pretty boring game with so little activity.

262
"No worries. Sleep well. I don't think I can sleep after all that..."

263
Relaxing slightly, Lastelle dismounts and starts moving towards the next carriage.

"Yeah. Largo, want to try cards again, or just take that nap?"

264
Mafia / Re: Exquisite Cops and Robbers II - Day 2
« on: February 18, 2021, 06:24:16 am »
Just realized I've made an assumption.

Tomasque: does the target of a roleblock know they were roleblocked?

265
Mafia / Re: Exquisite Cops and Robbers II - Day 2
« on: February 18, 2021, 06:17:24 am »
Btw, what's the argument for Secretdorf being town given that their lying has already led to the death of two townies?
Not much, beyond stronger evidence against others.

Though it is a little hypocritical of you to call them a liar and yourself confused for your similar situations.

Given that Toaster's not hammered yet I guess that clears them FMPOV. Still useless without King Zultan tho.
I agree that Toaster probably isn't scum unless you also are...if he has an effective vote, which I'm asking him to prove above.

266
Mafia / Re: Exquisite Cops and Robbers II - Day 2
« on: February 18, 2021, 05:17:08 am »
I see, you're claiming that your action was blocked. Well, I happen to know how that block works, from what I saw on D1. So let's put that to the test.

Everyone: Were you blocked last Night?

Toaster: Could you place your vote or votes? On me if you have no other preference. I want to see if your vote is effective.

267
Mafia / Re: Exquisite Cops and Robbers II - Day 2
« on: February 18, 2021, 04:37:43 am »
IcyTea:  Are you a hologram?
Yes. I wasn't actually day-revived, I just decided to delay my speaking up until the first votecount (and thus action resolution) to make that plausible. Therefore, Caz lied in trying to take credit for my revival:
Because why would I revive you if I was mafia lmao
Ok I realise I didn't explain my ability well, I revive someone and also give someone my vote (which is why I don't think roleflips can be inaccurate, imagine giving your vote to a maf and reviving a maf too? WHAT) Toaster has my vote, so they can't be maf, otherwise maf has 3/5 of the votes. (majority)
Incidentally, do you have two votes, Toaster? Caz still has a vote as can be seen from the votecount, so that's at least partially a lie.

268
Mafia / Re: Exquisite Cops and Robbers II - Day 2
« on: February 17, 2021, 10:25:50 am »
And I am thinking KZ has a vote or why will he have been invited. Its got so difficult to figure the real mafia. Icytea, you were mafia or it was tricmagic, you know the thing with true paladin and false paladin.
I see. So one labyrinth guard said that Tric was town, and the other said I was mafia? The answer to that would have been that we're the same alignment, not one town and one mafia.

What was the ability actually supposed to do?

This is the second time in a row in which someone has called the mod a bastard over a roleflip which should prove me town without a doubt.

269
Mafia / Re: Exquisite Cops and Robbers II - Day 2
« on: February 17, 2021, 06:00:17 am »
Oh damn. I wasn't expecting a votecount so soon. Yeah, I don't have a vote; I was trying to see if scum would try to hammer Caz, but that's inconclusive since nobody else posted since my vote.

However, it would seem that Caz lied about not having a vote. And also about reviving me, since I was revived by NQT's hologram ability.

270
Mafia / Re: Exquisite Cops and Robbers II - Day 2
« on: February 17, 2021, 05:57:04 am »
Toaster has my vote, so they can't be maf, otherwise maf has 3/5 of the votes. (majority)
I see, but it's actually 3/6 assuming King Zultan has a vote. Since FoU brought KZ into the game, they're likely the same alignment, and thus the scum!FoU world would also be at 3/6.

By process of elimination, this only leaves you and SD as possible mafiosi. However, since in this world you'd be scum, you'd also possibly be lying about giving Toaster your vote, making you and Toaster a possible scumteam.

Possibilities:
  • The scumteam is Caz/Secretdorf
  • The scumteam is Caz/Toaster
  • The scumteam is FallacyofUrist/KZ/(1 of: Caz, Secretdorf, Toaster), and a townie has an ability which makes defeat not inevitable

Pages: 1 ... 16 17 [18] 19 20 ... 621