Dodger is slow. I think ditching the shield helps. But shields stop missiles and effects like breaths. Ans as you saw with the Titan, dodging was just fine even though lower than shield.
I haven't tried a grate in ages. Not sure they work for fishing.
Embark is 5x5, which is large. I like large, though it means waiting out sieges at times (not that sieges are an issue here so far.) With a large embark the sieges can park fa enough away you can't drive them off without exposing your forces to great risk, compared to working from the walls to whittle them down, then charging out.
I don't know if I just screwed up handling the situation, or if it's a design problem with DF. Couldn't make any changes to military if not commander. Wouldn't let me appoint one, guessing because there was no village chief. I tried deleting the squad commander had been in, but then I couldn't create a new squad to see if that allowed the commander. It did not.
Then the village commander was appointed by AI and that let me create a new military commander... but recreating the squad (technically, creating a new one) it put it at the bottom of the list. Maybe I could have kept that first squad and slotted the commander back into the old slot. I don't know.
Wait, I could try restarting the spring save and see if that gives me a second try. That might result in a different set of deaths though. May try that when I go back to it.
Thanks for making me think about it all again. That caused me to remember I have a save right as these deaths happened. Didn't occur to me to save scum it.