Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[dakarian]

Cheetar, don't edit your posts.  Editing is not allowed in mafia.  If you forgot something or made a mistake, write another post (double posting is ok here)


That's 5 on Bulb now.  I think we're about done this day.

[Cheeetar]

Oh, sorry.

[bulborbish]

Vote Bulborbish

Good job other religion, you win

I wasn't on when you started to vote for Red, so I couldn't stop it.

[Kashyyk]

Thanks Eduren, forgot about that.

I suppose I ought to end the game? Let me think up some RP so I can do that properly.

[ToonyMan]

Wait so, the games over?

That was fun.

[dakarian]

As they say "All threats are removed"  The opposing religion is gone as are all who have a need to kill anyone else.  All townies have a 'Survive' goal since there's no Merc.  The big religion has no more threats so it can grow big enough to win anyway. 

There's only one issue: If Bulb recruited someone in Night 2, then it depends: if they are vanilla Agnostic, they win anyway.  If they are a power role, their role switched to 'religion wins' so they'll lose. 

And that's that.  I REALLY want to know you guys reasoning for that Night 1 kill: that was either an insane read or a crazy-lucky shot.

[Mr.Person]

It's amazing how even the best of mafia setups can be ruined by those damn players.

[dakarian]

Didn't seem ruined to me actually.  Most games end at the end of Day 3.  As for the number of folks surviving: this game was meant to have a lot of survivors.  It just has an odd ending that feel unfinished.

Night 1 was a lucky shot, but shouldn't have been a game killer.  Bulb's group lost their kill ability but gained the Mod as a recruit.  They effectively had control of the vote.  I was also in good relations with Xen from talks in Day 1 and I would've been sypathetic to the non-zealot religion.

So Bulb's group has their Prophet and Evan, the double voter and, with some risk and communication, the FBI agent. 

The problem: no one told Xen who the prophet was and both religion members went quiet.  I had expected the relilgious to get aggressive in the vote and try to draw out who was who.  I expected someone to notice I was very eager in Zealot killing.  Since no one did anything I figured you religious folks were hiding so I took a "Smoke em out or wipe em out" decision. 

The rest was luck.  Prophet died.  Recruit stolen who had knowledge of the Evan.  Rest is history.


If there's something that needs work from what I saw, it would be more motivation for the town to act.  That'll bring the religious out of hiding and help cover them during the day.  Of course, I'll know more once I see how the religions were planning things out. 

[ToonyMan]

As they say "All threats are removed"  The opposing religion is gone as are all who have a need to kill anyone else.  All townies have a 'Survive' goal since there's no Merc.  The big religion has no more threats so it can grow big enough to win anyway. 

There's only one issue: If Bulb recruited someone in Night 2, then it depends: if they are vanilla Agnostic, they win anyway.  If they are a power role, their role switched to 'religion wins' so they'll lose. 

And that's that.  I REALLY want to know you guys reasoning for that Night 1 kill: that was either an insane read or a crazy-lucky shot.

Games over, so why not?

I am the other Zealot.  I killed Servant Corps because, well, I didn't want the ArmChair to find us out, if he didn't clam ArmChair this game would have ended up very different.  We killed to prevent being found out, just luck he was actually the other zealot!  :-D

Our religion:

Pandarsenic - Prophet
Frelock - E-Evangelist
ToonyMan - Zealot
Xegeth - Recruited Night 2; Moderator

ACTIONS:

Night 1 - Kill Servant Corps
Night 2 - Convert Xegeth
Night 3 - We were going to kill Dakarian.

[Servant Corps]

You know, you could have just "converted" me rather than kill me. Especially Panda was just the Prophet.

But whatever. Here's the quicktopics for our religion and the dead chat.

[ToonyMan]

You know, you could have just "converted" me rather than kill me. Especially Panda was just the Prophet.

But whatever. Here's the quicktopics for our religion and the dead chat.

Bah.  I wouldn't fall for such.

Anyway, here's our religion talk:

http://www.quicktopic.com/43/H/Quhq7kpK9RqXL

[Leafsnail]

I think the problem might be that the "town" basically just decided to give up and try and get themselves converted.

[Mr.Person]

I think the problem might be that the "town" basically just decided to give up and try and get themselves converted.

Well, being converted proves to one religion you're not part of the other religion. Of course, I had the luxury of being proven on the town, so it's a moot point. Oh btw, thanks for staying in touch, religion that converted me.

[Eduren]

I was Armchair Theologian.

Night 1: Dakarian (Random) = Agnostic
Night 2: Mr.Person (Random) = Weak Religious

I dont think i would have ever roleclaimed after seeing what happened to Servant Corps.

[ToonyMan]

I was Armchair Theologian.

Night 1: Dakarian (Random) = Agnostic
Night 2: Mr.Person (Random) = Weak Religious

I dont think i would have ever roleclaimed after seeing what happened to Servant Corps.

I knew there was an Armchair, luckily you didn't hit one of us.