@Loud Whispers: Wouldn't a Titan be a bit of a tough fight even if your dwarves had weapons? :p
I expect 3-7 to die by the Titans directly, syndromes could increase this a bit
It's really a good way to live without flux. Or any metals. Or weapons. 2nd year in, I have 43 soldiers, 28 of whom would be able to take down sieges, and 12 marksmen. Crossbow spam is brilliant (and a requirement for above ground forts - damn buzzards).
One time I made an embark and played for a bit and this giant badger boar or whatever killed my hunter. This was annoying; it was like five minutes in. And the damn thing even got a name because of it. So I just threw all my remaining dwarves in to a squad and had them attack the giant badger boar. I was not overly surprised when the "wrestler squad" got destroyed piecemeal.
And that's how we get things done in my fortresses. All for one!
Cudgelslides has been more fortunate thus far.
Giant Badger boars can be scared away with dogs, just never engage them with untrained and unarmoured Dorfs
So yeah. No steel?
1. Recruit every useless migrant that arrives on your fortress into standard squads of 3 (and schedule for 2).
2. Reach a quota of recruiting above 50% of entire population.
3. Equip with whatever you can find.
?!?!?
4. Lotsa Dorfs are dead, but you now have a few elite supersoldiers.
Once you have pro. army up, recruit entire population. If all else really fails... Charge of the drunk brigade. (Over a hundred Dorfs charging a Titan is a beautiful sight in all of it's ASCII glory
)