FLASHBACK NO. 3It had been a long time since Morning Dew had last seen him, and now she was starting to show. She’d concealed it from the others before, but soon everypony would know. She forced a weak smile to her face. Maybe he’d come back. Maybe...
A knock came at her door. “Morning Dew? Are you home?”
Her heart started to leap in her chest. It was him! “Y-yes, I’m home,” she said.
“Uh, can I come in? There’s something I’d like to talk with you about,” he said, trying to keep the apprehension out of his voice.
“Yes, yes, please come in!” she said, walking slowly over to the door with the weight of her foal starting to hinder her movements.
As she opened the door, he looked her in the eyes and gave her a small sad smile. “There’s a few things we should talk about.” He stepped inside as she made room for him. “First off, I think I should apologize for... well, a lot.”
Morning Dew waves it away. “No...No, there’s nothing for
you to apologise for...” she says with a bit of a sad tone in her voice.
“Oh, but there is,” he said, still not looking directly at her. “I’ve been avoiding you for a while, because I lost something kind of important.” He looked up at her. He didn’t really need it. It was time to stop fooling around. “Something that I... thought... I...” he trailed off as his eyes rest on her. More importantly, something
new about her belly. He cocked his head. She couldn’t have just gained that much weight that fast.
Morning Dew just looked to him, hoping beyond hope he’d know why it was. “I...It’s my fault,” she said.
“Dew...” he began, raising an eyebrow. “Are... are you...
pregnant?”
“Yes,” she said, as her heart began to sink.
It felt like she had reached into his chest and ripped his beating heart from his body. He was too stunned to even say anything, and he took a step back. A few colorful emotions washed over his face, and he finally managed to say, “H-how... how
could you?”
“It... it was my fault. I’m sorry,” she said, her words sounding hollow even to her.
Her fault
indeed. “Your fault?” he said, letting a bit of anger rise in his voice. “I should say it’s your fault,” he went on. “How could you
do this to me?” he asked, his voice cracking slightly.
“I’m...I’m sorry,” she said as her first tear began to bead up.
“Sorry?
Sorry?” he demanded, letting tears of his own form in his eyes. “And-and to think...” he said, choking up too much to speak. He looked away, clenching his eyes shut and wiping away the tears. “I... I can’t
believe this...”
Morning Dew, the bottom having fallen out of her world, collapses onto her fore-hooves, and cried.
And as Morning Dew began to cry, the stallion backed up another step and wiped his eyes again. He couldn’t stop crying either. The mare he loved had gone and done
this to him. He couldn’t bear to look at her anymore, and barged out of her home without another word.
He bucked the door to his office open, slumped into his chair and buried his face in his hooves on the desk. “What did I do to deserve this?” Temperance whimpered between sniffles.

,

, Morning Dew, and

Temperance is sitting in his office as he does for much of the day, running the numbers and trying to prioritize how best to handle Flamberge’s requests. They had lots of wood growing around them, but it was starting to run out in their stockpiles. Could they cobble together twenty crossbows, plus set up a wooden wall, plus finish the hospital, plus make furniture with what they had? It was starting to look doubtful. He sighs and scratches the tables off the list. It looked like they would have to get by with bare bedrooms for a little while longer. There is a rapid pitter-patter of tiny hooves coming towards the door.
He looks up, curious who that could be. It didn’t sound like an adult, so it was probably just one of the sheep wandering out of the pasture again. They should probably look into getting a fence for that at some point. After this other mile long list of things to do, of course. There is a flash in the room, and little Mountain Dew appears. “Buh ubba!” she says.
Temperance is stunned for more than just a moment. He stands and walks over to the little filly, utterly confused at how she just appeared like that. Then his eyes rest on her horn, and it falls into place. “Mountain Dew? What are you doing here? Where’s your mommy?” he asks, kneeling next to her.
“Bluh buh,” says the foal, and looks around for something to play with... then finds it. The pony’s head! She jumps up, trying to get on the new jungle gym.
“Gah!” Temperance cries out as he’s suddenly treated to a face full of filly. He pries her free and sits on his haunches, holding her out in front of himself. “I should probably go find your mom.”
“Buh da buh,” agrees the foal. Meanwhile, while he’s not doing anything, she will mess up all his reports and lists and everything. No fun being restrained otherwise. Her horn glows, and the papers start to lift from the desk.
“Temperance’s eyes go wide as he sees his careful work being very uncarefully shuffled around. “Hey! No, no Mountain Dew, those aren’t for playing,” he says, setting her back on the ground as he tries to grab some of the floating sheets.
“Buh,” sighs the foal as she sees her fun taken away from her. Fortunately for her, she spots a pot of ink open, and her eyes go wide with delight. “Buh ub da!” she says, and her horn glows as the ink starts to rise out of the pot in her grasp.
Seeing his papers float around was one thing, but a pot of ink’s contents were much more alarming. He tries to grab as many papers as he can and get them out of the way of the floating disaster waiting to happen. “Mountain Dew, why don’t you just wait a second while I find you something to play with?”
“Bluh eba,” says the foal, finally agreeing to wait. But not waiting idle, of course. As her horn continues to glow, the ink starts forming an image of a heart, with two ponies inside. The sound of running hooves comes from outside, and the door bursts open with Morning Dew looking frantic, and Serenity looking only slightly less frantic. “Mountain Dew? Mountain Dew!” cries Morning Dew as she dashes over to the little foal. As she remembers whose office they are in, she bows her head. “Um. Mr Temperance. Um. I’m sorry if. If Mountain Dew was bothering you. Um. It’s my fault.” A tear begins to bead in her eye. “A-again.”
A slightly sad expression washes over Temperance’s face as he says, “No, no, it’s fine. She hasn’t hurt anything.” The giant blob of floating ink hadn’t permanently altered anything, yet anyway. The little heart image is almost distinct now, and Morning Dew can be recognised as one of the ponies in it, and the other an earth pony.
Amber magic envelops the floating ink, causing the image to dissipate and the whole thing to pour carefully back into the inkwell. “Still, we’re sorry to burst in on you like this.”
“It’s...It’s all my fault,” says Morning Dew, choking back a sob. “I’m sorry again...”
He sighs and steps over to her. “It’s okay. Really,” he says, resting a hoof on her withers.
“I-it isn’t!” she sobs, and runs out of the office.
Temperance gives Serenity a slightly puzzled look before he gallops off after her. “Dew! Dew, wait!” She’d obviously just been seeing Serenity, so being upset about something made sense.
Serenity thinks to follow them, but then realises that somepony must stay behind to watch over Mountain Dew. She looks around for the little filly. “Mountain?”
Mountain Dew is looking annoyed at Serenity, almost slightly angry. Once more, she picks up the ink from the ink pot.
Serenity catches the ink once more, returns it to the pot, and corks it firmly. “No.”
Mountain Dew pouts, and then gets another idea. She jumps onto the desk, and picking up one of the papers in her mouth, she lifts the words off of it. The words begin their transformation into the same heart that she was making with the ink.
Serenity sighs, and decides that the loss of one single sheet wasn’t so bad. She shifts the others out of Mountain’s reach, and sits down to watch. “What are you making there, little one?”
The image is of a heart. On one side is Morning Dew, or at least it looks like Morning Dew, and on the other is another earth pony. A stallion. One with a wavy mane and tail, and a short and thin body.
Serenity squints at the image of the stallion, quite unable to discern who it is. “...Is that your daddy, sweetie?”
The foal nods, and Serenity is probably able to recognise the cutie mark now.
Serenity sees the sealed scroll on the mystery pony’s flank, and chuckles. “Oh, no, sweetie. Mr. Temperance isn’t your daddy.”
The foal nods more emphatically, and the heart breaks apart, with a little foal next to Morning Dew and the two ponies looking unhappy. “Buh ubba,” says the foal firmly.
Serenity shakes her head. “No, that simply can’t be. He wouldn’t have left Morning Dew to raise you alone.”
“Bu bah?” points out the foal, indicating Temperance running after Morning Dew.
“He’s just concerned about her, that’s all.”
“Buh buh,” says the foal in a voice that radiates unconvincedness. Or maybe hungriness, it’s hard to tell when the foal is speaking meaningless syllables.
She stares at the image for a little while longer, a slight smile forming on her face. “...They
do make a cute couple... who knows? Maybe he
will be your daddy some day.”
“Buhbu!” the foal says again, once more pointing out to the clouds of dust almost settling down after Temperance’s passage.
Serenity shakes her head again. “No, it’s simply not possible! I highly doubt Temperance would forget falling in love with Morning Dew, or asking her to marry him, or... being...
drugged?” Her pupils shrink, and her face goes pale. Serenity turns tail and gallops out after Temperance. Mountain Dew shrugs, and starts running after her. Or to the kitchen, whichever is closer.
Temperance sees Morning Dew run into her room crying and slamming the door shut. Something inside him told him that he should probably just walk away before this got ugly, but he couldn’t. He trots up to the door and pauses a minute before knocking lightly with a hoof. “Dew? Please, what’s wrong?”
A gentle sob is all the reply he gets, muffled by the wall.
What now? Try to force his way in, or just talk to her through the wall? “Dew... please... can I come in? Mountain Dew didn’t hurt anything.” He tests the door, but finds that it is indeed shut. No simply slipping in.
“G-go away! Y-you’ll just hate me more!” cries Morning Dew.
A knot forms in Temperance’s gut, and for a moment he’s tempted to take her advice. Instead, he decides that this whole thing needed to be fixed. As much as it could be anyway. “Dew... I don’t hate you. I never have,” he says. That last bit might have been stretching it, for that one moment so long ago, but it was true now anyway.
“Y-y-you...you don’t?” she asks, as the sobbing pauses for a second.
“No, I don’t. Can I come in? Can we talk?”
“Um. Y-yes,” she says.
He eases the door open and steps inside. “Thanks.” He joins her at her bedside and asks, “Is that what’s bothering you? You thought I hated you?”
Morning Dew is hunched over, a few tears still running down her face as she clutches a little necklace in her hooves. “Y-y-yes,” she says through the tears.
Serenity comes galloping up to the pair. “Temperance!” She takes a moment to catch her breath. “Temperance... we need to talk.”
He looks up to her for a moment, and raises a hoof as if to say, “One moment.” He looks back down to Morning Dew, and says “Dew... you
broke my heart.” A few hints of moisture become evident in his eyes. “But I’m not a pony to hold grudges,” he lies.
“I-I-I’m s-s-sorry...I... I’m not good enough for you...” says Morning Dew, the tears beginning to start again.
“You were more than everything I could have hoped for,” he replies, all but choking up. “That’s why... why it hurt so much...” As he fights off sobbing of his own, he notices the necklace in her hooves. “...Dew... where did you find that?”
“Y-y-you g-g-gave it to me. T-t-that night,” she chokes out through the tears. “Y-y-you can h-h-have it back, if you want...”
Serenity gapes. “It was you... the whole time, it was you?”
Temperance was becoming genuinely curious what Serenity was talking about now. The necklace was almost too important to diverge from, but he hazards, “
What was me?”
“The stallion Morning Dew loves... Mountain Dew’s father... it’s
you.”
Temperance furrows his brow as he looks back and forth between the two mares. He certainly loved her once, and she loved him. Maybe she still did. But Mountain Dew? “No, no... I’m not her father. I...” He raises a hoof to his forehead. “I
can’t be.”
Serenity steps inside. “How good is your memory of that night? Rather fuzzy, I’d assume?”
“What night?” Temperance asks, growing only more confused.
“T-the night when you p-p-proposed to me,” Morning Dew says through the tears.
“But I... I didn’t?” he says, not really asking a question. He looks at the necklace, and an odd feeling washes through him. “I-I was
going to, but I lost the necklace. Then I was going to anyway... but...”
“As I suspected. Morning Dew...” Serenity sits beside her, helping her to her hooves. “I think it would be best if he heard it from you.”
“O-okay,” says Morning Dew, trying to blink back her tears. “I. I. That night. We’d had a salad. And. And I found something t-t-t-that I thought,” her lips start wobbling, “I thought it was a spice, s-something to add some flavour. A-a-and. You p-p-proposed to me. But. When we ate. You. You started acting strangely...and...and...” She bows her head, and stops speaking.
“But... but I... I don’t remember ever eating salad with you,” he says, frowning slightly. “I never did any of that...” ...did he?
“T-t-that’s the problem!” cried out Morning Dew. “I-I-I took some to C-C-Case Study, a-a-a-and it wasn’t a spice! It was a d-d-d-drug!”
“...what?” he squeaks. This was starting to make a frightening amount of sense.
“A-a-and...And...And...And it...it was all my fault... I-I-I told you you’d hate me more...” says Morning Dew as she hangs her head.
Temperance sits heavily. This was almost too much to believe. He still wasn’t sure he believed it. Maybe not all of it. A feeling of deep terror wells up inside him as an absolutely despicable thing enters his mind. “D-Dew... wh-what
exactly ha-appened? Wh-what did the drug do?”
“Y-y-you...You asked me if...if...because we were engaged now... and... I... I said yes,” said the mare.
He looks back at the necklace cradled in her hooves, and calms down slightly. “I... I see...” he says, still sitting motionlessly. How could he have done this? Was he not strong willed enough to resist?
“D-d-do...Do you still hate me?” Morning Dew asks, still tearing up.
He locks eyes with her, and slowly shakes his head. “No. No, I don’t hate you, Dew.” Seeing her like this was making him start to tear up too. Whether or not all of this was true, it was still as if one of the carpenters had just hit him in the face with a plank of wood. After a moment more, he scoots slightly closer to her, and lays a hoof on hers. “I never hated you.“
Mountain Dew finally arrives at the house, and runs into the room. “Bu lubba!” she says in excitement.
Serenity scoops up the little foal. “I think mommy and daddy need a little time alone.”
Temperance acknowledges the foal’s arrival with a puzzled look before he turns his attention back to Morning Dew. He keeps his hoof on hers, and asks, “Dew... if this is true... why? Why didn’t you
tell me?”
“I...I didn’t want to hurt you... I-I’m sorry...” she says as she hangs her head.
He starts thinking about the things he said to her that day, which was starting to feel like somepony was twisting a knife around in his stomach. “And you let me hurt
you like that?” he says, not trying to dry the tears that began to roll down his cheeks.
“Y-y-yes. I... I wanted, still want, you to be happy,” she says.
He shuts his eyes and takes a moment to level his breathing out before responding with, “But... all those things I said to you... all of it, and it was really
my fault.” He raises his other hoof to his chest, which was now aching. “Gasis forgive me...”
“I...I... D-d-d-do y-y-y-you forgive m-me?” she asks, lips trembling again.
“Forgive you?” he asks, his voice high and uneven. He makes a weak chuckle. “There’s nothing to forgive
you for. I should be asking you to forgive
me.” He shakes his head, recalling again the hurtful things he said. “Even if you forgive me... even if Gasis forgives me... I don’t know if
I could forgive myself.”
“I...but...But...w-w-w-will you still...will you still m-marry me?” she asks. “P-p-please?”
He makes another weak chuckle and wraps his hooves around her, drawing her into the tightest hug he could manage, which wasn’t much. “If you could ever forgive me.”
“I already do,” says Morning Dew.
He continues laughing weakly, pausing as he chokes up. He rubs her back with a hoof as he presses his face into her mane. “Then yes... yes. I
never stopped loving you.”
“T-t-thank you,” she says, her tears starting to stop. “I love you too, Temperance!”
Serenity smiles at the little filly in her hooves. “Okay,
now you can go.”
The little filly jumps out of Serenity’s hooves and runs up to the two and hugs their legs together.