Thoughts?
That's a really good review of the rounds. Simple, but it really helps me see it from your point of view. Anyway, my thoughts on the rounds? Well, I'm the one who made them, so I'll be biased, but I gotta say that they did feel more complex interesting as time went on. The early rounds were still good, but in a simple sort of way (might be because there were only 4 players, but the rounds felt simpler mechanic-wise as well).
Well, that's my thoughts on it, now I have a question of my own:
What are your opinions on the rounds being based off each stanza of "Fingertips?" Was it a cool idea? Was it a cheap gimmick? Does it make the rounds feel that much better, or should I have not tried to conform to anything and instead made my rounds from scratch?
And while I'm on that topic - yeah, I know my hints weren't that easy to find. My magnificent powers of hindsight reveal to me I fell into the standard trap - armed with all the knowledge of the rounds, the secret seemed more obvious to me than it did to you. It's a bit of a downer that only one person really found out in the end, but I guess that's better than no one.
Oh right.
They were tentative, but enough to work with, particularly seeing as the "answer" to one of the hints was mentioned specifically in the thread someplace.
You're referring to the one where I say something like "it's a song by my favorite band," right? Here's the link:
http://www.bay12forums.com/smf/index.php?topic=155932.msg6998257;topicseen#msg6998257 Also, how will we do the quote page? With the length of this thread, there will be a lot of good quotes - should I set up a google docs where we can compile them before we post them in-thread?
Author
Topic: Mafia Marathon (Read 220662 times)