All Player's Current Cases and Their Reasons
FallacyofUrist - 4maskwolf (low content voting), heydude6 (random vote?),
IcyTea31 - Jim Groovester (random vote with more reasons added later), Toaster ('scum slip')
Luckyowl - Nirur Torir (hasn't answered questions yet), NJW200 (for buddying IcyTea hard), Juicebox (bizarre playstyle), TricMagic (inconsistent logic - 4th vote on the wagon!)
Toaster - IcyTea31 (not having a town mindset), FallacyofUrist (random vote),
ToonyMan - dolores (disengaged style)
TricMagic - Leafsnail (posting from a scum mindset), ToonyMan and Vector (for persuing a 3rd party wincon)
Juicebox - Luckyowl (writing a wall of text is scummy?)
Nirur - notquitethere (low pressure pressure vote)
===
Quick Summary of How Bullshit These Cases Are In order of Most to Least
1 - Cases Of Dubious Substance
LuckyOwl, Leafsnail, Toaster, Jim Groovester, IcyTea31
2 - Low Effort Pressure & Random Voters Who Still Need To Form A Case
NQT, Heydude6, Nirur Torir, FallacyofUrist
3 - Cases That Don't Actually Hunt Mafia
Toonyman, Vector (third party hunting isn't necessarily bad but it is something that's very easy for scum to do productively while seeming active)
4- Cases Which Might Go Somewhere
NJW200, Juicebox, IcyTea, 4maskwolf, TricMagic, dolores
So right now I'm thinking, lynch out of #1 pile, and expand the pile to include any of #2 that don't come up with anything good. Review #3 on later days, and reassess #4 as and when new developments arise.