Bay 12 Games Forum

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Advanced search  
Pages: 1 2 [3] 4 5 ... 14

Author Topic: CYOM 5: Choose-Your-Own-Materia - Day One - Equivalent Exchange  (Read 1976 times)

TricMagic

  • Bay Watcher
    • View Profile
Re: CYOM 5: Choose-Your-Own-Materia - Day One Begins!
« Reply #30 on: May 03, 2025, 01:34:28 pm »

RNG favors me apparently.

My question is Meta: Who here submitted Steal, Clone, Commend, Propagate, Ban, Void-Gaze, and/or Sugar, and what do they do?
Logged

VermilionSkies

  • Bay Watcher
    • View Profile
Re: CYOM 5: Choose-Your-Own-Materia - Day One Begins!
« Reply #31 on: May 03, 2025, 02:32:07 pm »

oh god the mechanics

Tric: I can confirm I didn't submit any of your list, but that's not too helpful currently.

I'm a little shocked I don't see Warehouse 13 in the Materia list.

I made Dry, Ruin, and Glass.

Imp: Do you think you'll read me correctly this game?
Logged

Crystalizedmire

  • Bay Watcher
  • she/her
    • View Profile
Re: CYOM 5: Choose-Your-Own-Materia - Day One Begins!
« Reply #32 on: May 03, 2025, 04:15:01 pm »

RNG favors me apparently.

My question is Meta: Who here submitted Steal, Clone, Commend, Propagate, Ban, Void-Gaze, and/or Sugar, and what do they do?
Didn't submit any of those.

Gail 42: What have you learned last time from playing on this forum?
Logged
I like birds

ToonyMan

  • Bay Watcher
  • Danger Magnet
    • View Profile
Re: CYOM 5: Choose-Your-Own-Materia - Day One Begins!
« Reply #33 on: May 03, 2025, 04:58:32 pm »

How's everyone feeling, peachy?

RNG favors me apparently.

My question is Meta: Who here submitted Steal, Clone, Commend, Propagate, Ban, Void-Gaze, and/or Sugar, and what do they do?
Spoiler: The Answer Is (click to show/hide)

Help I don't know what I'm doing
Logged

Elephant Parade

  • Bay Watcher
    • View Profile
Re: CYOM 5: Choose-Your-Own-Materia - Day One Begins!
« Reply #34 on: May 03, 2025, 04:59:13 pm »

I finally got a job so I'm feeling pretty great.
Logged

Magma Mater

  • Bay Watcher
  • Stray Cat cancels hunt vermin: seeking infant.
    • View Profile
Re: CYOM 5: Choose-Your-Own-Materia - Day One Begins!
« Reply #35 on: May 03, 2025, 05:07:03 pm »

You're a little nervous. Okay, a lot nervous. A cute guy asked you out last week, and you've been biting your nails waiting for this day. It's an overcast Sunday morning, but just as the sun peeks through the clouds, a glint catches your eye. Magma Mater has arrived on the scene, the chrome of his Razor scooter gleaming in the filtered sunlight.

The two of you sit down for breakfast. You tug your hair as you browse the menu, half from anxiety, and half from jealousy; Magma's own hair is flowing luxuriously over his shoulders like a well-oiled batch of your mom's spaghetti. You glance up from the menu, and a jolt of electricity courses through your body as your eyes meet. He smiles and gently places a hand on your menu to lower it back to the table. "You won't be needing that dear, I know a better method," he confidently states, winking. Swooning, you barely manage a nod, wishing you still had the menu in front of your face to hide the blood rushing to it. As he flags down the nearest server, the restaurant seems to reverently hush itself to allow him to speak. "Garçon! A large bowl of your finest strawberry yoghurt, hold the strawberries."

After a bit of time yammering about whatever meaningless drudgery you keep yourself occupied with on the day-to-day, your meal arrives. A creamy mixture with a hint of pink, you eagerly seize your spoon and make a movement toward the bowl. Just before your utensil reaches the emulsion, however, Magma extends his hand and lowers your implement back to the table. "You won't be needing that dear, I know a better method," he remarks, winking. You watch in awe as he dips double digits into your breakfast, elegantly scooping a serving between his slavering lips.

A veil seems to drop upon the world. Everything is muffled, everything is dull, everything except for right here, these moments you have eating yoghurt with Magma Mater. His fingers glide effortlessly through it, gently delivering it to your mouth. You close your eyes and focus on the shape and warmth of his fingers contrasted by the sour tanginess of the cream. Your tongue dutifully explores every nook and wrinkle, retrieving what it can from under his fingernails. Then, his nose twitches slightly, and he withdraws his fingers to attend to it. A slight squelching sound emanates from his nostril as the yoghurt-covered appendage returns from its mining operation, leaving a pink ring as the only trace of its presence there. Soon enough, his fingers return to work serving the two diners.

Some time later, the bowl lies empty upon the table. You let out a deep sigh of satisfaction, leaning back in your chair. A wave of melancholy passes over you as you realize the end of your date is nigh. You offer to pay the bill - it's only fair, after all the work he did to ensure you were fed - and he graciously allows you the honour. Leading you by the arm, he escorts you outside. It's been such a great morning, and fearing its imminent end you invite him to spend the rest of the day at your apartment, but the gentleman declines. Instead, he leans down and bequeaths you the last of the yoghurt, still encrusted upon his lips. A pleasant metallic taste has been endowed upon it by his many coldsores, and you greedily lap up what you can. You plan your next date at the ramen shop across town, and smile contentedly as he rides his Razor scooter down the street and around the corner.
Logged

ToonyMan

  • Bay Watcher
  • Danger Magnet
    • View Profile
Re: CYOM 5: Choose-Your-Own-Materia - Day One Begins!
« Reply #36 on: May 03, 2025, 05:13:12 pm »

I count 32 materia, so with 11 players that means every player submitted 3 materia except one guy submitted 2.

Certain pairings are also likely the same player or are an extraordinary coincidence, such as:
Quote
Master Command
Master Magic
Master Summon
All start with Master, likely the same one player.

Quote
Caravan Palace
Monstrous Alliance
Mutualistic Magnification
Psychic Silence
Strategic Accretion
Thunderous Propagation
All use two big words, likely the same two players here.
(Not sure about Silver Star, it feels simpler and would add a third player to the pile if I added it to the list. One of the players who submitted two word materia also did some single word materia evidently.)

Vermilion
Quote
Dry
Glass
Ruin
They just openly admitted it earlier, but you can see how the words feel...connected regardless right? It's like you can read into a player's psyche just from single words...

Makes me fearful for whoever would submit "'Ng ゥ$◣ 8qZ", it's not alignment indicative at all (we all submitted materia before knowing our alignment), but that feels as one of corruption.
Logged

Imp

  • Bay Watcher
    • View Profile
Re: CYOM 5: Choose-Your-Own-Materia - Day One Begins!
« Reply #37 on: May 03, 2025, 05:22:42 pm »

oh god the mechanics

Tric: I can confirm I didn't submit any of your list, but that's not too helpful currently.

I'm a little shocked I don't see Warehouse 13 in the Materia list.

I made Dry, Ruin, and Glass.

Imp: Do you think you'll read me correctly this game?

Hello, one of my favorite people!

I suspect I may have a chance to read you correctly this game.  So far, you appear likely town.  I would **like** to have more to read before I start going off 1-post reads.  Also, if I appear or do need more to mark you, that makes it harder for you to know what I think I see, which helps increase the accuracy over time :D

I would really like you to be town this game though, for all the reasons you're likely to guess if you wonder; the teamwork-related stuff.  More on that later, I am still figuring out my role and options there.  Happily my alignment is clear and simple :D

RE: Warehouse 13 is missing, yeah.

So, Fallacy outright rejected my W13-related request last game I asked.

And then (like right then, during that game) life for me went weird in a mix of good and bad ways, and I now have a way to get my W13 fixes outside of mafia, or at least apply and be rejected, whatever may one day happen.

So, I got the sense that... people here might want more variety, + 'I can finally stop asking'.  Cool.  Beans.  And more, like the whole rest of the garden.  Now I can request other stuffs.  Turns out there's LOADS of interesting stuffs I can request instead.

I want us to remember that there COULD be mechanical benefit to knowing who submitted specific materia.  I do not have that mechanic personally at this time.  However, we are in a NQT BYOR-like/CYOS-like game.  So, maybe think about how revealing you choose to be about what you personally submitted.

For example, the odds of you having materia that you submitted is maybe higher than the odds of you not having it; if Tric or anyone had an ability that has a special affect if someone possesses the ability 'sugar', say, like he can destroy the target's 'sugar materia' (or give them diabetes KEYWORD, or some other reason why he'd wanna know that), he might really want that info and each of us may or may not want to share it.

Tric, I can't think of a way to ask you about that question you asked without sounding to me it's fishing.  Would be townie fishing, but if you wanna say anything, I'm reading.

Yay for EP's job!  And for feeling great!  I... am currently semi-stable compared to how I was recent games.  This is likely to change unpredictably, but I am probably 'more sane' than I have been the last few games, since Fal's game where I first couldn't be W13-related.

So, I'm more feeling... beef heart braised with butternut squash, Toony, than peachy :D  But for me for now, it's kinda 'all right'.

Also, Toons.  It's possible that everyone submitted 3, and for 2 players, one of their 3 submissions collapsed together into 1.
Logged
For every trouble under the sun, there is an answer, or there is none.
If there is one, then seek until you find it.
If there is none, then never ever mind it.

Imp

  • Bay Watcher
    • View Profile
Re: CYOM 5: Choose-Your-Own-Materia - Day One Begins!
« Reply #38 on: May 03, 2025, 05:27:16 pm »

You're a little nervous. Okay, a lot nervous. A cute guy asked you out last week, and you've been biting your nails waiting for this day. It's an overcast Sunday morning, but just as the sun peeks through the clouds, a glint catches your eye. Magma Mater has arrived on the scene, the chrome of his Razor scooter gleaming in the filtered sunlight.

The two of you sit down for breakfast. You tug your hair as you browse the menu, half from anxiety, and half from jealousy; Magma's own hair is flowing luxuriously over his shoulders like a well-oiled batch of your mom's spaghetti. You glance up from the menu, and a jolt of electricity courses through your body as your eyes meet. He smiles and gently places a hand on your menu to lower it back to the table. "You won't be needing that dear, I know a better method," he confidently states, winking. Swooning, you barely manage a nod, wishing you still had the menu in front of your face to hide the blood rushing to it. As he flags down the nearest server, the restaurant seems to reverently hush itself to allow him to speak. "Garçon! A large bowl of your finest strawberry yoghurt, hold the strawberries."

After a bit of time yammering about whatever meaningless drudgery you keep yourself occupied with on the day-to-day, your meal arrives. A creamy mixture with a hint of pink, you eagerly seize your spoon and make a movement toward the bowl. Just before your utensil reaches the emulsion, however, Magma extends his hand and lowers your implement back to the table. "You won't be needing that dear, I know a better method," he remarks, winking. You watch in awe as he dips double digits into your breakfast, elegantly scooping a serving between his slavering lips.

A veil seems to drop upon the world. Everything is muffled, everything is dull, everything except for right here, these moments you have eating yoghurt with Magma Mater. His fingers glide effortlessly through it, gently delivering it to your mouth. You close your eyes and focus on the shape and warmth of his fingers contrasted by the sour tanginess of the cream. Your tongue dutifully explores every nook and wrinkle, retrieving what it can from under his fingernails. Then, his nose twitches slightly, and he withdraws his fingers to attend to it. A slight squelching sound emanates from his nostril as the yoghurt-covered appendage returns from its mining operation, leaving a pink ring as the only trace of its presence there. Soon enough, his fingers return to work serving the two diners.

Some time later, the bowl lies empty upon the table. You let out a deep sigh of satisfaction, leaning back in your chair. A wave of melancholy passes over you as you realize the end of your date is nigh. You offer to pay the bill - it's only fair, after all the work he did to ensure you were fed - and he graciously allows you the honour. Leading you by the arm, he escorts you outside. It's been such a great morning, and fearing its imminent end you invite him to spend the rest of the day at your apartment, but the gentleman declines. Instead, he leans down and bequeaths you the last of the yoghurt, still encrusted upon his lips. A pleasant metallic taste has been endowed upon it by his many coldsores, and you greedily lap up what you can. You plan your next date at the ramen shop across town, and smile contentedly as he rides his Razor scooter down the street and around the corner.


I imagine your partner/the protagonist there is primarily Gail?

Did you write much of that or was it fully commissioned, as that goes?

What interpretations would you like me to make from this?
Logged
For every trouble under the sun, there is an answer, or there is none.
If there is one, then seek until you find it.
If there is none, then never ever mind it.

ToonyMan

  • Bay Watcher
  • Danger Magnet
    • View Profile
Logged

Imp

  • Bay Watcher
    • View Profile
Re: CYOM 5: Choose-Your-Own-Materia - Day One Begins!
« Reply #40 on: May 03, 2025, 05:32:01 pm »

nsfw erotica
Spoiler (click to show/hide)

Yeah, the reason why I asked 'Gail?' is because I thought I remembered Gail discussing yogurt in the Discord.

Nope, "Dude, that's like the cherry topping that cupcake :heh:" along with attraction-like interest to a pink-haired person.  My mind went there, but where did Mater aim for and why?  Why?  WHY?
Logged
For every trouble under the sun, there is an answer, or there is none.
If there is one, then seek until you find it.
If there is none, then never ever mind it.

Elephant Parade

  • Bay Watcher
    • View Profile
Re: CYOM 5: Choose-Your-Own-Materia - Day One Begins!
« Reply #41 on: May 03, 2025, 05:33:06 pm »

I have three guesses for what Tric is doing, two of which I won't spell out:
1) He's making a specific play that's comprehensible but probably not very effective.
2) He's making a different, totally useless play because he missed a certain piece of information.
3) He's scum trying to get information on materia he didn't submit. Throwing a grenade in the role lake frame 1 feels like a town!Tric play so this is the least likely universe.
Logged

zemaj

  • Bay Watcher
    • View Profile
Re: CYOM 5: Choose-Your-Own-Materia - Day One Begins!
« Reply #42 on: May 03, 2025, 05:34:00 pm »

<snip>
zemaj: Why a Z instead of an S?

I explained this elsewhere, but that may have been discord gen-chat, so not surprised you missed it.  Basically, I chose it back when I (and the internet in general) was younger and thought using the 'Z' instead of 'S' was 'unique' and 'cool' and 'edgy' (this was before that word had the negative connotation it has today).  I use the same(ish) SN in most communities, for continuity between, and it has led to me meeting the same people in different communities, which I personally think is pretty neat.  So I just continue using it.



RNG favors me apparently.

My question is Meta: Who here submitted Steal, Clone, Commend, Propagate, Ban, Void-Gaze, and/or Sugar, and what do they do?

I submitted Thunderous Propagation.  On attack, it gives target a copy of one of attackers equipped materia, and makes a Thunderclap.  On defend it give +1 defend slot & prevents your actions from making Thunderclaps.  On accessory, it changes any random materia received to a copy of a random materia equipped.


How did you come up with that specific list?



ToonyMan:- got any good memes to start us off with. (PPE, yep!)  Also, hey.

Everyone: - Do you think sharing specific information about our specific materia is more help or hinderance to town or mafia in this setup?  Why?
Logged
And I'm getting along real well with Zem in and out of game, so I just want him alive forever (In fact, I have no kill, so I don't get to say who dies, and I would have been SO HAPPY to tell the game of a maf inspect on him, though I would have considered chances of redirection in that case as well - least now I don't need to really try to read him for alignment, which is great.)

Magma Mater

  • Bay Watcher
  • Stray Cat cancels hunt vermin: seeking infant.
    • View Profile
Re: CYOM 5: Choose-Your-Own-Materia - Day One Begins!
« Reply #43 on: May 03, 2025, 05:38:28 pm »

You're a little nervous. Okay, a lot nervous. A cute guy asked you out last week, and you've been biting your nails waiting for this day. It's an overcast Sunday morning, but just as the sun peeks through the clouds, a glint catches your eye. Magma Mater has arrived on the scene, the chrome of his Razor scooter gleaming in the filtered sunlight.

The two of you sit down for breakfast. You tug your hair as you browse the menu, half from anxiety, and half from jealousy; Magma's own hair is flowing luxuriously over his shoulders like a well-oiled batch of your mom's spaghetti. You glance up from the menu, and a jolt of electricity courses through your body as your eyes meet. He smiles and gently places a hand on your menu to lower it back to the table. "You won't be needing that dear, I know a better method," he confidently states, winking. Swooning, you barely manage a nod, wishing you still had the menu in front of your face to hide the blood rushing to it. As he flags down the nearest server, the restaurant seems to reverently hush itself to allow him to speak. "Garçon! A large bowl of your finest strawberry yoghurt, hold the strawberries."

After a bit of time yammering about whatever meaningless drudgery you keep yourself occupied with on the day-to-day, your meal arrives. A creamy mixture with a hint of pink, you eagerly seize your spoon and make a movement toward the bowl. Just before your utensil reaches the emulsion, however, Magma extends his hand and lowers your implement back to the table. "You won't be needing that dear, I know a better method," he remarks, winking. You watch in awe as he dips double digits into your breakfast, elegantly scooping a serving between his slavering lips.

A veil seems to drop upon the world. Everything is muffled, everything is dull, everything except for right here, these moments you have eating yoghurt with Magma Mater. His fingers glide effortlessly through it, gently delivering it to your mouth. You close your eyes and focus on the shape and warmth of his fingers contrasted by the sour tanginess of the cream. Your tongue dutifully explores every nook and wrinkle, retrieving what it can from under his fingernails. Then, his nose twitches slightly, and he withdraws his fingers to attend to it. A slight squelching sound emanates from his nostril as the yoghurt-covered appendage returns from its mining operation, leaving a pink ring as the only trace of its presence there. Soon enough, his fingers return to work serving the two diners.

Some time later, the bowl lies empty upon the table. You let out a deep sigh of satisfaction, leaning back in your chair. A wave of melancholy passes over you as you realize the end of your date is nigh. You offer to pay the bill - it's only fair, after all the work he did to ensure you were fed - and he graciously allows you the honour. Leading you by the arm, he escorts you outside. It's been such a great morning, and fearing its imminent end you invite him to spend the rest of the day at your apartment, but the gentleman declines. Instead, he leans down and bequeaths you the last of the yoghurt, still encrusted upon his lips. A pleasant metallic taste has been endowed upon it by his many coldsores, and you greedily lap up what you can. You plan your next date at the ramen shop across town, and smile contentedly as he rides his Razor scooter down the street and around the corner.


I imagine your partner/the protagonist there is primarily Gail?

Did you write much of that or was it fully commissioned, as that goes?

What interpretations would you like me to make from this?

I'd like for the reader to insert themselves into the shoes of the protagonist. It was intentionally written with an ungendered protagonist, for accessibility reasons.
I did write it myself. I was inspired by Gail's reaction to my "put your fingers in the pudding and stir it around" post last game.

I've hidden the names of my materia in the post, for posterity.

And before anyone asks, it is purely a work of fiction. I do not actually own a Razor scooter.  :(
Logged

Imp

  • Bay Watcher
    • View Profile
Re: CYOM 5: Choose-Your-Own-Materia - Day One Begins!
« Reply #44 on: May 03, 2025, 05:41:38 pm »

Everyone: - Do you think sharing specific information about our specific materia is more help or hinderance to town or mafia in this setup?  Why?

I view it as similar to revealing abilities in any other game.

Let's focus on 'alignment inspect' because that does not exist in this game.

If I was an alignment cop, should I reveal this... I presume 'now' though your question doesn't have a time?

Presuming there's redirects, blocks, and various ways to go meta and direct, knowing who claims they can do what can indeed be useful for everyone.

Do you think we should we play this game differently than we'd play other games, in terms of what we reveal and don't?
Logged
For every trouble under the sun, there is an answer, or there is none.
If there is one, then seek until you find it.
If there is none, then never ever mind it.
Pages: 1 2 [3] 4 5 ... 14