Dariush:So.
IronyOwl, did you just:
1) claim to be a werecreature in a game where the enemies are WEREWOLVES;
Yes. Do you have a point here?
2) did so immediatly before Toaster got lynched;
If you wanted me to claim earlier you should have voted to extend. Or at least made it clear that you weren't going to, in a pinch. I was all in favor of giving everyone time to properly assess my claim (as well as other things), but aside from Native I was apparently the only one.
3) despite previously softclaiming vig?
There really wasn't any other way to do it without looking awkward or claiming straight up. It was more intended to be an example than a literal claim, though.
And that's not mentioning voting the pretty much guaranteed town ZU.
I have no idea what you're talking about. How was ZU guaranteed town?
Up till now I was under expression that fakeclaiming (even fakesoftclaiming) as PGO in order to attract kills is a bad idea, since it would also attract protects. Do you not think so?
And which of these do you think is more common?
Furthermore, if this was my plan why would I switch to PGO, ie
the exact opposite for both goals, at the last minute?
webadict:HOWEVER. You have stumbled onto one particular clue completely by accident. In the opening pages of the game, Mephensteras clearly says this:
Roles: The available town roles will be known.
Therefore, IronyOwl, having claimed a role other than those listed on the page, cannot be town.
There's more reasoning, but I'm afraid that I'm going to have to let Dariush finish his explanations, just in case he's simply kicking dirt around.
Yeah, I thought that was odd too. You'll notice Fortune Teller (Toaster's old role) isn't on that list either, so either it's out of date, covers broad archetypes rather than specific rolenames, or there's some strange alignment/role change condition for at least two players. I could potentially see something like that for me, but I don't see how it'd apply to a Fortune Teller, and simply being similar enough to the scumteam to be alarming sounds like a more likely catch regardless.
He never claimed vig. He softclaimed it. He was trying to attract someone to kill him, which shows more that he isn't a werewolf.
If only. Alas, the lack of a kill two nights in a row was too important to leave unexplained.
Imiknorris and Native:I have no actions. NativeForeigner and I are coven witches. (web: witches = masons)
You know for a fact that you're both Town, then?
Orangebottle:This vote has very little in the way of actual justification. You're voting him because Toaster said so(which is incredibly lazy), because he's been acting as his meta says he should be if he were town, and because you don't think there could be three priests. Oh, but wait, there could be any number of roles in the game. Removing priests isn't the only way that Meph could balance them; they could be impious(as evidenced by Toaster's botched ressurection).
I'm voting him because Toaster's logic started to seem more plausible, not because I'm blindly obeying Toaster. Perhaps that was worded poorly.
I'd also like more information out of him, because I don't have much yet. Do you object to me voting Darvi in an attempt to scumhunt him? What
would be an acceptable reason to vote Darvi to you?
Finally, I never said three priests was impossible. I said I was dubious of it, and would like his opinion on it. Do you think fakeclaiming scum taking credit for a priest rez is impossible? Which do you think is more likely- three priests or fakeclaiming scum taking credit for a slain one?
And speaking of low-justification votes, nice bandwagon chainsaw of Darvi.
Because I didn't want him getting anywhere near LYLO. Survivors near LYLO are dangerous, as are SKs(which is what I thought he was before he flipped).
He was an outed "SK" claiming to be willing to work for town. What about a puppet vig was so dangerous that he had to be dealt with on Day 2 to prevent him reaching LYLO? Didn't you have any better targets? Did you have any other targets at all?
Powder Miner, I don't like people who ignore my questions. I still want your reasoning on Toaster, and I especially want to know why you didn't extend.
Author
Topic: Supernatural 5 - Ended (Read 99927 times)