Anyway, in all seriousness, this time, AnimePigeon.
Sal, you're a grey area. And I've seen you not fight hard when you've been grey area anti-town and headed likely down. You kinda fail efficiently. That's a relatively new pattern, not that many games with you, but I wonder if that's what I see here and if that's your pattern these days. You are PoE to me.
Not at all. In fact I simply don't think I'm "going down" this time. But, like ToonyMan, if I say the magic words, I die. I have to weigh whether to say them. If it comes down to it, I will. But, you know me. It's hard to convince myself to self-sacrifice.
I will say that I think it's almost certainly Anime, with ToonyMan the less likely alternative. Nobody else had to be on the Agentt wagon at any time. It's not that I can't imagine alternate realities - I can easily imagine the alternate reality where Imp decides to be a brutal bus-thrower instead of a caring mother hen this time, to keep the rest of us guessing, and gleefully lampshades it by talking about being extra evil in the thread, for just one example - but I think that's where most of the probability lies.
Have we decided who we're voting yet?
I'm thinking Magma.
My brain says you or AnimePigeon no matter what.
It's not me, but if you want me dead, I can deliver it.
You don't understand me at all. It's sad.
I expect to vote AP today.
What was your thought process at End of Day 1?
I already explained it. I planned to vote out Agentt, but I wanted to spend as much time as possible without the lynch being a foregone conclusion, because the hammer-free setup makes votes lower-information than usual. Keeping the set of viable alternatives open longer means that I learn more from where people choose to put their votes. I was especially interested in getting you to move your vote when I tied it, although it is true that Jim moved his first; I was considering who was and was not advocating for an Agentt lynch, and I saw you as potentially on the "not" side, so I wanted to see where you'd go.
I also had side objectives relating to making the best use of my role, but you don't need to know about that.
Kind of confused about the rationale behind the dopp kill but not going to complain that the dopps are helping me solve the game.
I'm a Sneak. I was roommates with Magma Mater during N1 (he didn't know). Magma Mater didn't leave his house, so he is not a doppelganger.
My D1 game suspects have all been solved, so now I have to work through Imp, ToonyMan, notquitethere, Salvatore Monday, and AnimePigeon.
If it isn't Magma, the strongest likelihood is AnimePigeon.
This would also, arguably, explain a completely nonsensical kill target from our perspective.
I went to quite a lot of effort d1 to give scum every opportunity to be off-wagon and not feel like the only chance was to bus. Of course we do have players who would bus that hard d1 for no particular reason — fully aware that I'm certainly one of them for the rest of you — but hopefully night results will clear that up.
The progression from Salvatore is only getting more puzzling.
Certain on Magma Mater, AnimePigeon, Magma Mater, AnimePigeon...
Salvatore you keep going on about how it's sad that I'm Tunnelling you and that I don't understand you, your right - I don't understand you, as imo your play makes 0 sense as a Townie - it only makes sense as a Doppelgänger or Alien.
I've given you plenty of times to enlighten me on what I'm misinterpreting or misunderstanding about you, yet you fail to provide more than complaints about my inability to read you.
Hence why I'm
Salvatore MondayMy heart wants to vote Magma so bad but Jim has denied this passion.
What if Jim's evil?
Here is the annoying thing, Jim can definitely be Evil & I don't think anyone (atleast not me) has suggested they are completely clear.
But then you've got a strange shape of;
Salvatore attempted convincing Imp of Evil!AnimePigeon &/or Evil!Magma,
Salvatore attempted convincing Toony of Evil!Magma &/or Evil!Jim,
Jim attempted convincing that Good!Magma means Evil!AnimePigeon - because despite having an initial POE of just 2 people (for 2 Evil/Neutral Roles), instead of figuring out an expanded POE, clearing Good!Magma, seemingly just negates the need to search for the additional Evil (assuming I was Evil).
NQT, Imp & Toony have been very vocal & open about there considerations, they haven't jumped from person to person, they have laid out Pros/Cons, and attempted to move forward from that.
I'm inclinded to believe Magma is Good!Magma regardless of Jim's result, as Magma seems to have a reason to believe both me & Jim are Good!
Author
Topic: Paranormal Mafia 28 - Game Over! Town victory (Read 13817 times)