Re: EuchreJack's D1 meltdown: People have brought it up and used it to townread EuchreJack. I don't think it strongly indicates alignment in his favor. I could see him doing that as scum.
Well, whatever. The question for me now is whether I should believe in the Toony and Jim who disbelieve in me.
... ehhhh, alea iacta est. You two better not be the team or I'll be mad.
notquitethere
Hmmmmmmmmmmmmm.
But what does it mean when people I suspect suddenly join me in voting other people I suspect?
Hrrrrmmmm.
This is fair, people do change their mind, but I was pointing out that Toony literally contradicted himself. He said there was something he liked in my play then later he said he had seen nothing he liked in my play all game. Well, maybe this is null and I'm being too sensitive as I'm the target of his slander here, but it felt to me that his play matched that of someone setting me up as a viable lynch candidate. You know, something he's just done.
'he said a nice thing about me and then he lied and said he never said nice things about me'
lmao its okay notquitethere, it'll all be okay, it's nothing to get sad about
Motivated reasoning is a big danger in mafia, but it's also hard to avoid. We have a bad feeling about someone, we go looking and lo there are reasons to support that feeling. At the time I made that case that's about all I had to work with.
I understand, but what it should be, at least in my opinion, is 'my bad feelings are directly caused by these things' rather than 'i have a bad feeling, here is a collection of evidence that support that'. There's a difference between the two and by my reading you're admitting to doing the latter rather than the former.
Max - Lazy opportunistic wagoner whose defence is he's always like that.
Now THAT'S a barb and a not completely unconvincing one as well.
So, if NQT flips town, we all lynch Toony, right? Right.
I'm going to keep my vote on Toony, but he's put in great effort to win everyone over, so I understand if folks decide to let him live. It's not like he didn't earn it.
Hrmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm.
Run me through how you think there is exactly one scum between notquitethere and ToonyMan.
Not really a fan of the either/or attitude here.
Hold up. I log back in and I'm the lynch lead? Serves me right for taking my foot off the pedal.
Toonyman, obviously. But I actually prefer actually-useless Fluffe as a candidate for today.
A thing people should know if they've been scum with me is that I don't actually like to bus. Especially at the start of the game, it's usually counterproductive. No way am I in a scum team with Jack. Firstly, I'm not scum. Secondly, I don't reckon he is either. Well probably not. But thirdly, if I was scum, I wouldn't have tried to launch him so hard on D1.
Anyway, I suspect that this kind of defence will not be well received. More in a bit.
Relevant: http://www.bay12forums.com/smf/index.php?topic=180323.0
In that game, NQT should have bussed hector13, but instead hard-defended. Town still lynched hector13, roleblocked NQT, then lynched NQT the next day for the win.
Thank you for providing evidence supporting the assertion that you and notquitethere are not likely to be on a scumteam together.
Why do you bring this up?
Why does this feel like it's answering questions nobody asked? I know people have theorized you and NQT as partners but I don't think people are executing Day 2 as if it's the dominant theory.
And furthermore, if you can wade through the 3+ pages of Toony Spam, you'll see that I have been making a case for Toony.
I have no idea what your case is on ToonyMan and I read Day 2 last night.
If it's between Toon or NQT im going to vote ToonyMan although personally i'd rather vote A1 I just ain't gonna cause I feel trying to start a bus at this point for A1 would be futile and I don't actually have much in the way of evidence to back it up.
Why not vote a1s and see if you can convince people to join you?
Choosing a lynch often comes down to negotiation and compromises between players on who they are okay with removing from the game. You might find people to take you up on voting a1s (but not me).
The game got much more complicated since my last post. I have a lot of concern focused within notquitethere/Maximum Spin/EuchreJack.
I'll be traveling today to visit family so I might not be around as much. I probably miss the deadline tomorrow.
Author
Topic: Wormwood Mafia - Game Over (Read 33489 times)